Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Dismissal without prior warning is invalid: the case of the Pride Month flag in the staff room

Dismissal without prior warning is invalid: the case of the Pride Month flag in the staff room

In June 2025, a legal offi­cer at the Fede­ral Office for Migra­ti­on and Refu­gees (BAMF) hung a so-cal­led ‘Pri­de Month’ flag in his office. This flag is visual­ly model­led on a rain­bow flag and is regard­ed as a sym­bol of a cam­paign direc­ted against the LGBTIQ com­mu­ni­ty. Accor­ding to the 2024 Report on the Pro­tec­tion of the Con­sti­tu­ti­on, it is used pri­ma­ri­ly by right-wing and far-right groups. What makes this case par­ti­cu­lar­ly note­wor­t­hy is that the room ser­ved not only as an office but also as a hea­ring room for asyl­um pro­cee­dings, whe­re asyl­um see­kers, inter­pre­ters and lawy­ers regu­lar­ly gather.

A serious breach of duty, but not grounds for dismissal without prior warning

The Gies­sen Labour Court made it clear that dis­play­ing the flag in this con­text con­sti­tu­tes a serious breach of ancil­la­ry obli­ga­ti­ons under the employ­ment con­tract. Public sec­tor employees, par­ti­cu­lar­ly tho­se respon­si­ble for deci­ding on asyl­um appli­ca­ti­ons, are bound by the state’s requi­re­ment of neu­tra­li­ty. For peo­p­le who are per­se­cu­ted on account of their sexu­al iden­ti­ty or ori­en­ta­ti­on in par­ti­cu­lar, the pre­sence of such a flag in the office of the decis­i­on-maker respon­si­ble sends a dis­tur­bing signal.

Nevert­hel­ess, the court ruled that the dis­mis­sal was not jus­ti­fied on social grounds. The Sta­te of Hes­se had given the employee noti­ce of dis­mis­sal with effect from 30 Sep­tem­ber 2025 wit­hout first issuing a writ­ten war­ning. It was pre­cis­e­ly this that led to the dis­mis­sal being upheld.

Proportionality as a key criterion

Accor­ding to the estab­lished case law of the Fede­ral Labour Court, dis­mis­sal on grounds of con­duct requi­res that the­re be a nega­ti­ve pro­gno­sis for the future; in other words, it must be expec­ted that the employee will repeat their mis­con­duct. This was not the case here. The employee in ques­ti­on had remo­ved the flag imme­dia­te­ly upon being asked to do so, had express­ly distanced hims­elf from far-right and anti-LGBTQ+ atti­tu­des, and had, on his own initia­ti­ve, enrol­led in an anti-dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on trai­ning cour­se. In the court’s view, the fact that this step may also have been taken out of fear of losing his job ser­ved all the more to rule out any risk of repetition.

A for­mal war­ning would have been suf­fi­ci­ent and appro­pria­te as a less seve­re mea­su­re. Such a war­ning may only be wai­ved if a chan­ge in beha­viour is not to be expec­ted from the out­set, or if the breach of duty is so serious that con­tin­ued employ­ment is cle­ar­ly unre­asonable for the employ­er. The court ruled that neither of the­se con­di­ti­ons applied.

The behaviour of the line managers made the dismissal even more difficult to bear

Ano­ther aspect of the jud­ge­ment is par­ti­cu­lar­ly reve­al­ing: the aut­ho­ri­ty had fai­led to react to the flag being dis­play­ed for weeks. Alt­hough the employee’s imme­dia­te line mana­ger spo­ke to him, she did not expli­cit­ly ask him to take it down. Nor did the head of depart­ment, who had been infor­med, take any action at first. It was only when ano­ther mem­ber of manage­ment inter­ven­ed that the flag was remo­ved. The employee’s sus­pen­si­on ulti­m­ate­ly took place at the same time as his dis­mis­sal, i.e. more than six weeks after the inci­dent itself.

The court regard­ed this hesi­tant approach as con­tra­dic­ting the sub­se­quent asser­ti­on that the rela­ti­onship of trust had been irrepa­ra­b­ly dama­ged. Anyo­ne who remains inac­ti­ve for weeks in the face of an alle­gedly into­le­ra­ble breach of duty can­not, at the same time, cla­im that con­tin­ued employ­ment is unreasonable.

What does the ruling mean for employers?

The ruling shows that even serious brea­ches of the duty of neu­tra­li­ty do not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly jus­ti­fy imme­dia­te dis­mis­sal. Employ­ers, inclu­ding govern­ment bodies, must adhe­re to the prin­ci­ple of pro­por­tio­na­li­ty and, as a rule, issue a writ­ten war­ning first. Fur­ther­mo­re, an employ­er who is initi­al­ly hesi­tant to respond to mis­con­duct ther­eby jeo­par­di­ses the vali­di­ty of their grounds for dismissal.

Employ­ers and the employees con­cer­ned should seek advice on employ­ment law in spe­ci­fic cases.

Gies­sen Labour Court, jud­ge­ment of 22 April 2026, Case No. 6 Ca 220/25

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this