In June 2025, a legal officer at the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (BAMF) hung a so-called ‘Pride Month’ flag in his office. This flag is visually modelled on a rainbow flag and is regarded as a symbol of a campaign directed against the LGBTIQ community. According to the 2024 Report on the Protection of the Constitution, it is used primarily by right-wing and far-right groups. What makes this case particularly noteworthy is that the room served not only as an office but also as a hearing room for asylum proceedings, where asylum seekers, interpreters and lawyers regularly gather.
A serious breach of duty, but not grounds for dismissal without prior warning
The Giessen Labour Court made it clear that displaying the flag in this context constitutes a serious breach of ancillary obligations under the employment contract. Public sector employees, particularly those responsible for deciding on asylum applications, are bound by the state’s requirement of neutrality. For people who are persecuted on account of their sexual identity or orientation in particular, the presence of such a flag in the office of the decision-maker responsible sends a disturbing signal.
Nevertheless, the court ruled that the dismissal was not justified on social grounds. The State of Hesse had given the employee notice of dismissal with effect from 30 September 2025 without first issuing a written warning. It was precisely this that led to the dismissal being upheld.
Proportionality as a key criterion
According to the established case law of the Federal Labour Court, dismissal on grounds of conduct requires that there be a negative prognosis for the future; in other words, it must be expected that the employee will repeat their misconduct. This was not the case here. The employee in question had removed the flag immediately upon being asked to do so, had expressly distanced himself from far-right and anti-LGBTQ+ attitudes, and had, on his own initiative, enrolled in an anti-discrimination training course. In the court’s view, the fact that this step may also have been taken out of fear of losing his job served all the more to rule out any risk of repetition.
A formal warning would have been sufficient and appropriate as a less severe measure. Such a warning may only be waived if a change in behaviour is not to be expected from the outset, or if the breach of duty is so serious that continued employment is clearly unreasonable for the employer. The court ruled that neither of these conditions applied.
The behaviour of the line managers made the dismissal even more difficult to bear
Another aspect of the judgement is particularly revealing: the authority had failed to react to the flag being displayed for weeks. Although the employee’s immediate line manager spoke to him, she did not explicitly ask him to take it down. Nor did the head of department, who had been informed, take any action at first. It was only when another member of management intervened that the flag was removed. The employee’s suspension ultimately took place at the same time as his dismissal, i.e. more than six weeks after the incident itself.
The court regarded this hesitant approach as contradicting the subsequent assertion that the relationship of trust had been irreparably damaged. Anyone who remains inactive for weeks in the face of an allegedly intolerable breach of duty cannot, at the same time, claim that continued employment is unreasonable.
What does the ruling mean for employers?
The ruling shows that even serious breaches of the duty of neutrality do not automatically justify immediate dismissal. Employers, including government bodies, must adhere to the principle of proportionality and, as a rule, issue a written warning first. Furthermore, an employer who is initially hesitant to respond to misconduct thereby jeopardises the validity of their grounds for dismissal.
Employers and the employees concerned should seek advice on employment law in specific cases.
Giessen Labour Court, judgement of 22 April 2026, Case No. 6 Ca 220/25
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.