Anyone who gifts shares in a limited partnership must, for the purposes of gift tax, consider, amongst other things, the concept of new fundsexamine. This relates to a provision in the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act (ErbStG) which restricts the scope of the so-called business assets exemption. The Münster Finance Court has now clarified, in a ruling of practical relevance, the conditions under which such ‘new’ financial resources can arise in the first place.
What are young funds?
The Inheritance Tax Act provides for substantial tax relief on the transfer of business assets. However, this relief is not granted without restriction. Certain assets, including what are known as ‘recent funds’, are excluded from this relief. Funds are regarded as ‘recent’ if they were received by the business less than two years before the date of taxation, i.e. if they were contributed shortly before the gift was made. This is intended to prevent cash or other funds from being deliberately transferred into business assets shortly before a transfer in order to benefit from the tax exemption.
The case: Shareholders’ claims transferred to the capital reserve
In this specific case, the donor and the donee were both limited partners in a limited partnership (KG). In November 2018, both transferred their respective claims against the KG to the partnership’s joint assets. For accounting purposes, this was recorded as an entry in the capital reserve held in joint ownership. A few months later, on 31 March 2019, the donor transferred his limited partnership interest to the claimant free of charge.
The relevant tax office took the view that the transfers in 2018 had resulted in new financial resources, and assessed their value at over 356,000 euros. This assessment would have significantly increased the gift tax liability.
The court finds that there was neither a withdrawal nor a deposit
The 3rd Chamber of the Münster Finance Court rejected this view and set the value of the new funds at zero euros. The decisive factor was whether the accounting transactions were, for income tax purposes, to be treated as Insertare to be regarded as such. This is because the Act explicitly links the concept of ‘new funds’ to contributions and withdrawals for the purposes of income tax.
Under the principles of income tax law, the transfer of an asset from a limited partner’s special business assets to the joint assets the sameIn a partnership, this does not constitute a withdrawal or a contribution. Whilst the legal owner may change, in economic terms the assets remain within the same partnership. The court also emphasised that the concept of ‘new funds’ is not equivalent to that of ‘new administrative assets’, which is why the relevant case law cannot be applied automatically.
By way of further clarification, the court stated that even if a capital contribution were to be accepted, the statutory offsetting requirement under section 13b(4)(5), second sentence, of the Inheritance Tax Act (ErbStG) would have meant that, ultimately, no new funds would have been generated.
What does this mean in practice?
The ruling is relevant to anyone wishing to gift or bequeath shares in partnerships. It demonstrates that not every transfer of assets within a partnership automatically results in ‘new funds’ that are disadvantageous for tax purposes. However, the distinction is complex and depends heavily on the principles of income tax law. As the Münster Finance Court has granted leave to appeal to the Federal Finance Court (BFH), the final word on this matter has not yet been spoken.
Reference number:Münster Regional Court, Judgment of 16 July 2026, 3 K 682/24 EW
Anyone planning business succession or a gift should have the tax implications carefully assessed in advance by a tax adviser.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.