Anyone who operates a tourist guest card and, in doing so, passes on payments to service providers such as museums, leisure facilities or tourist attractions, may not claim input tax on those payments. This was ruled by the Baden-Württemberg Finance Court in a judgement dated 10 November 2025 (Ref. 14 K 2134/23). The court classified the card in question as a so-called multi-purpose voucher, which has far-reaching consequences under VAT law.
How the model worked
In the case in question, a limited liability company (GmbH) offered a guest card which allowed overnight guests in the region to access various tourist attractions free of charge. To this end, the GmbH entered into two types of contract: with the hosts – that is, hotels or holiday let providers – and with the service providers – that is, the operators of the attractions.
The hosts paid a sum of money to the GmbH for each guest staying for at least two nights. The GmbH retained at least 15 per cent of this to cover its costs and passed the remainder on to the service providers in accordance with actual usage. The limited liability company issued invoices to both parties showing VAT separately and claimed input tax on the payments made to the service providers. The tax office refused to allow the deduction.
The court found that there was no direct link to the benefit
The 14th Senate upheld the tax office’s view. An input tax deduction requires that a trader has himself procured a service for his business. This was not the case here. The tourism services were not provided to the limited liability company (GmbH), but to the guests. From the perspective of an average consumer, the guests are clearly the recipients of these services. The fact that the GmbH paid the consideration did not alter this.
In the court’s view, there was also no exchange of services subject to VAT between the GmbH and the hosts. Whilst the cost of the card is factored into the accommodation prices, the exact proportion cannot be determined and varies depending on the host. Nor did the court recognise any intermediary service provided by the GmbH to the hosts.
Even if VAT has been incorrectly declared, it is still payable
Particularly controversial: the court found that the GmbH had wrongly shown VAT on its invoices to the hosts. Under Section 14c of the Value Added Tax Act, it is nevertheless liable for this tax simply by virtue of it being shown on the invoice. This means: paying tax without being able to deduct input tax at the same time.
Appeal pending before the Federal Fiscal Court
The GmbH has lodged an appeal. The case is pending before the Federal Fiscal Court under reference number V R 3/26. A final ruling by Germany’s highest tax court is therefore still pending.
What does this mean in practice?
Operators of similar bonus or loyalty card schemes, where third-party services are offered as a bundle, should have their VAT treatment carefully reviewed. Classification as a multi-purpose voucher has significant implications for input tax deduction and invoicing. In case of doubt, it is advisable to seek expert tax advice before issuing invoices showing VAT.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.