Works council members serve in a voluntary capacity and may not receive any separate remuneration for their work as works council members. Whilst this may sound straightforward at first, in practice it is anything but simple. This is because, although the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG) expressly stipulates that the role must be performed without remuneration, the employer must continue to pay the works council member’s wages during the periods in which they are carrying out their duties on the works council. This is laid down in Section 37(2) of the BetrVG.
The principle of loss of earnings as a fundamental rule
Pay during leave of absence is based on the so-called ‘loss of earnings’ principle. This means that the employer pays exactly what the employee would have earned had they worked as normal during that period. This includes not only the basic salary, but also allowances, overtime pay and other variable components of remuneration that would have been payable had the employee not been carrying out their works council duties.
To put it figuratively, the employer keeps a sort of ‘shadow payslip’ for each works council member: they hypothetically work out what the employee would have earned had they not held this voluntary position, and pay exactly that amount. It sounds like a lot of work – and it is.
Prohibition of discrimination and preferential treatment
The situation is further complicated by the strict prohibition set out in Section 78 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG). Works council members must neither be disadvantaged nor given preferential treatment on account of their office. This expressly applies to remuneration as well. Anyone who is granted time off work as a works council member may therefore not receive a pay rise that exceeds what comparable colleagues without a works council mandate would have received. Conversely, however, the time off work must not result in the person concerned falling behind in their normal career progression.
Legislative changes in 2024 will provide greater clarity
In 2024, both Section 37 and Section 78 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG) were amended. One of the triggers for this was a judgement by the Federal Court of Justice dated 10 January 2023 (Case No. 6 StR 133/22), in which the court clarified that excessive remuneration for works council members could constitute a breach of trust. As a result of this judgement, many companies reduced the remuneration of their works council members, which led to a wave of legal action.
The amendment to the law codified the previous case law of the Federal Labour Court and provided several clarifications:
- The relevant date for determining comparable employees is the date on which they first take up their post as a works council member.
- The employer and the works council may agree, in a works agreement, on a procedure for determining comparable employees.
- Remuneration higher than the minimum rate is permissible if it is objectively justified and has been set without any error of discretion.
Federal Labour Court ruling 2025: Qualifications acquired later in life may also count
In a recent judgement dated 13 August 2025 (Case No. 7 AZR 174/24), the Federal Labour Court ruled that employers must take into account any qualifications acquired by a works council member during their term of office when determining their remuneration. However, this does not apply to skills directly related to works council activities, such as negotiation skills gained from collective bargaining.
What this means for employers and employees
Both employers and full-time works council members face a complex calculation task. Errors in calculating remuneration can lead to legal action or, as the VW ruling shows, may even result in criminal consequences. Anyone who is unsure how to calculate remuneration correctly should seek legal advice.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.