Cross-border workers employed in Switzerland who receive daily benefits from the statutory Swiss accident insurance scheme following an accident there need to be aware that, whilst this benefit is tax-free in Germany, it does increase the tax rate on their other income via the so-called ‘progression clause’. The Federal Fiscal Court has clarified this in a recent ruling.
What is the progression clause?
The progression clause means that, whilst certain tax-exempt income is not itself subject to tax, it is nevertheless taken into account when calculating the individual’s tax rate. The result is that income subject to tax is taxed at a higher rate than it would be if the tax-exempt income did not exist at all.
The case before the Federal Fiscal Court
In this specific case, an employee lived in Germany and was employed by a Swiss company. As a so-called cross-border worker, he regularly commuted between his home in Germany and his place of work in Switzerland. In Switzerland, he was compulsorily insured under the local accident insurance scheme by law. When he suffered a private cycling accident and was temporarily unable to work, the Swiss accident insurance scheme paid him a daily allowance amounting to 80 per cent of his insured earnings.
The tax office recognised that this payment was tax-exempt, but included the daily allowance in the calculation of the progressive tax rate. The claimant challenged this decision all the way to the Federal Fiscal Court.
Decision: Daily allowance is comparable to German sick pay
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) dismissed the appeal as unfounded. The court found that the Swiss daily sickness allowance is comparable to the sickness benefit provided by the German statutory health insurance scheme under Book V of the Social Code (SGB V). Both benefits serve the same purpose: they protect employees against loss of earnings resulting from incapacity for work due to illness or accident. Both benefits are regulated by law, are paid as cash benefits and are based on previous earnings. The fact that the Swiss daily sickness allowance, at 80 per cent, is slightly more generous than the German sickness benefit, at 70 per cent, does not alter their fundamental comparability.
No comparison with private accident insurance
The court also expressly distinguished Swiss daily sickness benefits from benefits provided by private accident insurance. Private accident insurance typically only pays out in the event of permanent disability, i.e. permanent physical impairment. Swiss daily sickness benefits, on the other hand, apply even in the case of temporary incapacity for work. This structural difference means that the benefits are not comparable.
What does this mean for cross-border commuters?
Anyone working in Switzerland as a cross-border worker and receiving benefits from the statutory accident insurance scheme there should be aware that these payments can significantly increase the German tax rate on other income. This applies both to accidents at work and to private accidents occurring outside the journey to and from work. In specific tax cases, it is advisable to consult a tax adviser at an early stage in order to correctly assess the tax implications of the progression clause.
Federal Fiscal Court (BFH), judgement of 24 June 2026, case number VI R 26/24, published on 20 August 2026
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.