Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Swiss daily accident benefit is subject to the progression clause

Swiss daily accident benefit is subject to the progression clause

Cross-bor­der workers employ­ed in Switz­er­land who recei­ve dai­ly bene­fits from the sta­tu­to­ry Swiss acci­dent insu­rance sche­me fol­lo­wing an acci­dent the­re need to be awa­re that, whilst this bene­fit is tax-free in Ger­ma­ny, it does increase the tax rate on their other inco­me via the so-cal­led ‘pro­gres­si­on clau­se’. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has cla­ri­fied this in a recent ruling.

What is the progression clause?

The pro­gres­si­on clau­se means that, whilst cer­tain tax-exempt inco­me is not its­elf sub­ject to tax, it is nevert­hel­ess taken into account when cal­cu­la­ting the individual’s tax rate. The result is that inco­me sub­ject to tax is taxed at a hig­her rate than it would be if the tax-exempt inco­me did not exist at all.

The case before the Federal Fiscal Court

In this spe­ci­fic case, an employee lived in Ger­ma­ny and was employ­ed by a Swiss com­pa­ny. As a so-cal­led cross-bor­der worker, he regu­lar­ly com­mu­ted bet­ween his home in Ger­ma­ny and his place of work in Switz­er­land. In Switz­er­land, he was com­pul­so­ri­ly insu­red under the local acci­dent insu­rance sche­me by law. When he suf­fe­r­ed a pri­va­te cycling acci­dent and was tem­po­r­a­ri­ly unable to work, the Swiss acci­dent insu­rance sche­me paid him a dai­ly allo­wan­ce amoun­ting to 80 per cent of his insu­red earnings.

The tax office reco­g­nis­ed that this pay­ment was tax-exempt, but included the dai­ly allo­wan­ce in the cal­cu­la­ti­on of the pro­gres­si­ve tax rate. The clai­mant chal­len­ged this decis­i­on all the way to the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court.

Decision: Daily allowance is comparable to German sick pay

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) dis­missed the appeal as unfoun­ded. The court found that the Swiss dai­ly sick­ness allo­wan­ce is com­pa­ra­ble to the sick­ness bene­fit pro­vi­ded by the Ger­man sta­tu­to­ry health insu­rance sche­me under Book V of the Social Code (SGB V). Both bene­fits ser­ve the same pur­po­se: they pro­tect employees against loss of ear­nings resul­ting from inca­pa­ci­ty for work due to ill­ness or acci­dent. Both bene­fits are regu­la­ted by law, are paid as cash bene­fits and are based on pre­vious ear­nings. The fact that the Swiss dai­ly sick­ness allo­wan­ce, at 80 per cent, is slight­ly more gene­rous than the Ger­man sick­ness bene­fit, at 70 per cent, does not alter their fun­da­men­tal comparability.

No comparison with private accident insurance

The court also express­ly distin­gu­is­hed Swiss dai­ly sick­ness bene­fits from bene­fits pro­vi­ded by pri­va­te acci­dent insu­rance. Pri­va­te acci­dent insu­rance typi­cal­ly only pays out in the event of per­ma­nent disa­bi­li­ty, i.e. per­ma­nent phy­si­cal impair­ment. Swiss dai­ly sick­ness bene­fits, on the other hand, app­ly even in the case of tem­po­ra­ry inca­pa­ci­ty for work. This struc­tu­ral dif­fe­rence means that the bene­fits are not comparable.

What does this mean for cross-border commuters?

Anyo­ne working in Switz­er­land as a cross-bor­der worker and recei­ving bene­fits from the sta­tu­to­ry acci­dent insu­rance sche­me the­re should be awa­re that the­se pay­ments can signi­fi­cant­ly increase the Ger­man tax rate on other inco­me. This appli­es both to acci­dents at work and to pri­va­te acci­dents occur­ring out­side the jour­ney to and from work. In spe­ci­fic tax cases, it is advi­sa­ble to con­sult a tax advi­ser at an ear­ly stage in order to cor­rect­ly assess the tax impli­ca­ti­ons of the pro­gres­si­on clause.

Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH), jud­ge­ment of 24 June 2026, case num­ber VI R 26/24, published on 20 August 2026

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this