Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Noise in block of flats: When tenants may reduce their rent and landlords may give notice

Noise in block of flats: When tenants may reduce their rent and landlords may give notice

Whe­ther it’s roos­ters on the neigh­bou­ring pro­per­ty, loud foot­s­teps from the flat abo­ve or com­mer­cial music les­sons in the block of flats: noi­se is a regu­lar issue befo­re Ger­man courts. Howe­ver, not every dis­tur­ban­ce auto­ma­ti­cal­ly gives rise to a legal cla­im. The decisi­ve fac­tor is always whe­ther the dis­tur­ban­ce exceeds the level cus­to­ma­ry for the loca­li­ty and beco­mes unre­asonable for tho­se affec­ted. A sel­ec­tion of key jud­ge­ments illus­tra­tes whe­re the boun­da­ries lie.

Termination of tenancy due to noise: Landlords must proceed with care

If ten­ants dis­turb one ano­ther with noi­se and the dis­pu­te escala­tes, ter­mi­na­ti­on wit­hout noti­ce may be jus­ti­fied. Howe­ver, land­lords must not act arbi­tra­ri­ly in such cases. The Flens­burg Regio­nal Court quas­hed the noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on ser­ved on a long-stan­ding ten­ant becau­se the land­lord should first have cla­ri­fied who was pri­ma­ri­ly respon­si­ble for the con­flict. All par­ties invol­ved must be heard befo­re indi­vi­du­al noti­ces of ter­mi­na­ti­on are issued. (Flens­burg Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 17 April 2026, 1 S 64/25)

The situa­ti­on was dif­fe­rent in the case of com­mer­cial gui­tar les­sons in a ren­ted flat. In this case, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce upheld a ter­mi­na­ti­on wit­hout noti­ce: anyo­ne who regu­lar­ly holds com­mer­cial les­sons in pre­mi­ses let exclu­si­ve­ly for resi­den­ti­al pur­po­ses wit­hout the landlord’s per­mis­si­on, and ther­eby dis­turbs the peace of the house­hold, gives the land­lord the right to ter­mi­na­te the ten­an­cy on excep­tio­nal grounds. (Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce, jud­ge­ment of 10 April 2013, VIII ZR 213/12)

Hens, roosters and the barking of dogs: animal noise in court

Whe­ther noi­se made by ani­mals must be tole­ra­ted depends very much on the indi­vi­du­al case. Three courts have taken dif­fe­rent approa­ches to this issue:

  • The Colo­gne Regio­nal Court ruled that neigh­bours do not have to tole­ra­te the irre­gu­lar cro­wing of roos­ters in an urban resi­den­ti­al area. A noi­se log and a video show­ed that neither a peaceful night’s sleep nor undis­tur­bed use of the gar­den were pos­si­ble. The neigh­bour was entit­led to bring an action for an injunc­tion. (Colo­gne Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 21 May 2025, 13 S 202/23)
  • The Koblenz Regio­nal Court took a dif­fe­rent view in the case of a pre­do­mi­nant­ly rural area: anyo­ne kee­ping 25 hens and a cocke­rel the­re is enga­ging in an acti­vi­ty cus­to­ma­ry for the loca­li­ty. Neigh­bours must tole­ra­te the noi­se. (Koblenz Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 19 Novem­ber 2019, 6 S 21/19)
  • Cro­wing at night bet­ween 10.00 pm and 6.00 am, on the other hand, is gene­ral­ly not to be tole­ra­ted, even in rural are­as. The Mos­bach Regio­nal Court upheld the cla­im for an injunc­tion becau­se the sta­tu­to­ry night-time quiet hours app­ly. (Mos­bach Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 31 May 2023, 5 S 47/22)

The Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Hamm has set spe­ci­fic time limits regar­ding dog bar­king: more than 30 minu­tes a day or more than 10 minu­tes at a time is unre­asonable. (Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Hamm, jud­ge­ment of 11 April 1988, 22 U 265/87)

Rent reduction due to noise: What counts as a defect?

Noi­se from a neigh­bou­ring flat may entit­le a ten­ant to a rent reduc­tion if it signi­fi­cant­ly impairs their use of the flat. The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) has cla­ri­fied that the ten­ant need only descri­be the spe­ci­fic pro­blem. The rent reduc­tion then takes effect auto­ma­ti­cal­ly by ope­ra­ti­on of law. In the case in ques­ti­on, a ten­ant had sought a rent reduc­tion due to kno­cking noi­ses, hea­vy foot­s­teps and fur­ni­tu­re being moved in the flat abo­ve. The BGH quas­hed a noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on wit­hout noti­ce that had been issued in respon­se. (BGH, ruling of 21 Febru­ary 2017, VIII ZR 1/16)

Con­s­truc­tion noi­se from the neigh­bou­ring pro­per­ty, on the other hand, does not gene­ral­ly con­sti­tu­te a defect in the ten­an­cy if the land­lord has no means of pre­ven­ting it. (Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce, jud­ge­ment of 29 April 2020, VIII ZR 31/18)

Children’s noise enjoys special protection

Under the Fede­ral Immis­si­on Con­trol Act, noi­se from play­grounds, nur­se­ries and simi­lar faci­li­ties is not gene­ral­ly con­side­red a harmful envi­ron­men­tal impact and must be tole­ra­ted. Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) empha­si­s­es that limits do app­ly in this regard as well. In indi­vi­du­al cases, the decis­i­on depends on the natu­re, dura­ti­on, time of day and inten­si­ty of the noi­se, as well as on whe­ther edu­ca­tio­nal or struc­tu­ral mea­su­res would be pos­si­ble. (Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce, ruling of 22 August 2017, VIII ZR 226/16)

Anyo­ne who feels dis­tur­bed by noi­se in their flat or on their pro­per­ty should, as a first step, keep a noi­se log and try to dis­cuss the mat­ter with the per­son caus­ing the noi­se. If the pro­blems per­sist, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal advice, as the line bet­ween accep­ta­ble and unac­cep­ta­ble noi­se depends on many factors.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this