Whether it’s roosters on the neighbouring property, loud footsteps from the flat above or commercial music lessons in the block of flats: noise is a regular issue before German courts. However, not every disturbance automatically gives rise to a legal claim. The decisive factor is always whether the disturbance exceeds the level customary for the locality and becomes unreasonable for those affected. A selection of key judgements illustrates where the boundaries lie.
Termination of tenancy due to noise: Landlords must proceed with care
If tenants disturb one another with noise and the dispute escalates, termination without notice may be justified. However, landlords must not act arbitrarily in such cases. The Flensburg Regional Court quashed the notice of termination served on a long-standing tenant because the landlord should first have clarified who was primarily responsible for the conflict. All parties involved must be heard before individual notices of termination are issued. (Flensburg Regional Court, judgement of 17 April 2026, 1 S 64/25)
The situation was different in the case of commercial guitar lessons in a rented flat. In this case, the Federal Court of Justice upheld a termination without notice: anyone who regularly holds commercial lessons in premises let exclusively for residential purposes without the landlord’s permission, and thereby disturbs the peace of the household, gives the landlord the right to terminate the tenancy on exceptional grounds. (Federal Court of Justice, judgement of 10 April 2013, VIII ZR 213/12)
Hens, roosters and the barking of dogs: animal noise in court
Whether noise made by animals must be tolerated depends very much on the individual case. Three courts have taken different approaches to this issue:
- The Cologne Regional Court ruled that neighbours do not have to tolerate the irregular crowing of roosters in an urban residential area. A noise log and a video showed that neither a peaceful night’s sleep nor undisturbed use of the garden were possible. The neighbour was entitled to bring an action for an injunction. (Cologne Regional Court, judgement of 21 May 2025, 13 S 202/23)
- The Koblenz Regional Court took a different view in the case of a predominantly rural area: anyone keeping 25 hens and a cockerel there is engaging in an activity customary for the locality. Neighbours must tolerate the noise. (Koblenz Regional Court, judgement of 19 November 2019, 6 S 21/19)
- Crowing at night between 10.00 pm and 6.00 am, on the other hand, is generally not to be tolerated, even in rural areas. The Mosbach Regional Court upheld the claim for an injunction because the statutory night-time quiet hours apply. (Mosbach Regional Court, judgement of 31 May 2023, 5 S 47/22)
The Higher Regional Court of Hamm has set specific time limits regarding dog barking: more than 30 minutes a day or more than 10 minutes at a time is unreasonable. (Higher Regional Court of Hamm, judgement of 11 April 1988, 22 U 265/87)
Rent reduction due to noise: What counts as a defect?
Noise from a neighbouring flat may entitle a tenant to a rent reduction if it significantly impairs their use of the flat. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has clarified that the tenant need only describe the specific problem. The rent reduction then takes effect automatically by operation of law. In the case in question, a tenant had sought a rent reduction due to knocking noises, heavy footsteps and furniture being moved in the flat above. The BGH quashed a notice of termination without notice that had been issued in response. (BGH, ruling of 21 February 2017, VIII ZR 1/16)
Construction noise from the neighbouring property, on the other hand, does not generally constitute a defect in the tenancy if the landlord has no means of preventing it. (Federal Court of Justice, judgement of 29 April 2020, VIII ZR 31/18)
Children’s noise enjoys special protection
Under the Federal Immission Control Act, noise from playgrounds, nurseries and similar facilities is not generally considered a harmful environmental impact and must be tolerated. However, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) emphasises that limits do apply in this regard as well. In individual cases, the decision depends on the nature, duration, time of day and intensity of the noise, as well as on whether educational or structural measures would be possible. (Federal Court of Justice, ruling of 22 August 2017, VIII ZR 226/16)
Anyone who feels disturbed by noise in their flat or on their property should, as a first step, keep a noise log and try to discuss the matter with the person causing the noise. If the problems persist, it is advisable to seek legal advice, as the line between acceptable and unacceptable noise depends on many factors.
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.