Freelancers who have hitherto been permitted to pay their VAT only upon actual receipt of payment must now take a closer look following a recent Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) ruling: those who keep accounts voluntarily lose this advantage. This was decided by the Federal Fiscal Court in its judgement of 16 April 2026 (Ref. V R 16/24).
Theoretical or actual taxation: what is the difference?
Under German VAT law, there are two basic methods by which businesses must calculate and pay their VAT. In the case of the Target taxationThe tax liability arises as soon as the invoice is issued, regardless of whether the customer has actually paid the invoice. This means that the business owner must pay the tax in advance. In the case of Taxation on an actual basisBy contrast, VAT is only payable once the money has actually been credited to the account. This represents a significant cash-flow advantage, particularly for smaller businesses and self-employed people with long payment terms.
Who is eligible to use the actual taxation scheme?
The tax office may approve taxation on an actual basis upon application. One of the conditions is that the annual turnover does not exceed 800,000 euros, or that the taxpayer belongs to the so-called liberal professions, such as lawyers, tax advisers, doctors or chartered accountants. In practice, the following has applied to freelancers to date: taxation on an accrual basis is possible regardless of the level of turnover.
The specific case: a law firm as a partnership
The case in question concerned a partnership comprising solicitors, auditors and tax advisers. Since its formation in 2006, the partnership had voluntarily kept accounts and determined its profit by means of a business assets comparison. At the same time, it opted for taxation on the basis of actual results. The tax office revoked the relevant authorisation in 2020.
The case was initially heard by the Baden-Württemberg Finance Court, which dismissed the claim (judgement of 9 July 2024, ref. 9 K 86/24). The Federal Finance Court has now upheld this decision and dismissed the claimant’s appeal as unfounded.
Reasons given by the Federal Fiscal Court
The court made it clear that anyone who keeps accounts on a voluntary basis and determines their profit by comparing business assets is not entitled to taxation on an actual basis under section 20, first sentence, no. 3 of the Value Added Tax Act (UStG). This means that self-employed professionals who keep accounts voluntarily are treated in the same way for VAT purposes as limited companies, such as a GmbH, which are required to keep accounts and which are also unable to apply taxation on an accrual basis.
Important for practical purposes: Simply maintaining lists of outstanding items is not sufficient in itself to constitute voluntary bookkeeping. Only when the profit for income tax purposes is actually determined by means of a comparison of business assets is this regarded as voluntary bookkeeping for the purposes of VAT law.
What does that mean in practice?
Freelancers who have so far been using the ‘actual’ taxation method and determining their profit by comparing business assets should urgently review their VAT situation. They may need to switch to the ‘target’ taxation method, which could lead to increased liquidity requirements. The method used to determine profits and whether voluntary bookkeeping is actually in place is often a matter to be assessed on a case-by-case basis. Tax advice is strongly recommended in this regard.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.