Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Freelancers lose the right to taxation on actual income if they opt for voluntary bookkeeping

BFH: Self-employ­ed indi­vi­du­als who keep accounts on a vol­un­t­a­ry basis lose their entit­le­ment to taxa­ti­on on actu­al tur­no­ver for VAT purposes. 
Freelancers lose the right to taxation on actual income if they opt for voluntary bookkeeping

Freelancers lose the right to taxation on actual income if they opt for voluntary bookkeeping

Free­lan­cers who have hither­to been per­mit­ted to pay their VAT only upon actu­al receipt of pay­ment must now take a clo­ser look fol­lo­wing a recent Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) ruling: tho­se who keep accounts vol­un­t­a­ri­ly lose this advan­ta­ge. This was deci­ded by the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court in its jud­ge­ment of 16 April 2026 (Ref. V R 16/24).

Theoretical or actual taxation: what is the difference?

Under Ger­man VAT law, the­re are two basic methods by which busi­nesses must cal­cu­la­te and pay their VAT. In the case of the Tar­get taxa­ti­onThe tax lia­bi­li­ty ari­ses as soon as the invoice is issued, regard­less of whe­ther the cus­to­mer has actual­ly paid the invoice. This means that the busi­ness owner must pay the tax in advan­ce. In the case of Taxa­ti­on on an actu­al basisBy con­trast, VAT is only paya­ble once the money has actual­ly been cre­di­ted to the account. This repres­ents a signi­fi­cant cash-flow advan­ta­ge, par­ti­cu­lar­ly for smal­ler busi­nesses and self-employ­ed peo­p­le with long pay­ment terms.

Who is eligible to use the actual taxation scheme?

The tax office may appro­ve taxa­ti­on on an actu­al basis upon appli­ca­ti­on. One of the con­di­ti­ons is that the annu­al tur­no­ver does not exceed 800,000 euros, or that the tax­pay­er belongs to the so-cal­led libe­ral pro­fes­si­ons, such as lawy­ers, tax advi­sers, doc­tors or char­te­red accoun­tants. In prac­ti­ce, the fol­lo­wing has appli­ed to free­lan­cers to date: taxa­ti­on on an accru­al basis is pos­si­ble regard­less of the level of turnover.

The specific case: a law firm as a partnership

The case in ques­ti­on con­cer­ned a part­ner­ship com­pri­sing soli­ci­tors, audi­tors and tax advi­sers. Sin­ce its for­ma­ti­on in 2006, the part­ner­ship had vol­un­t­a­ri­ly kept accounts and deter­mi­ned its pro­fit by means of a busi­ness assets com­pa­ri­son. At the same time, it opted for taxa­ti­on on the basis of actu­al results. The tax office revo­ked the rele­vant aut­ho­ri­sa­ti­on in 2020.

The case was initi­al­ly heard by the Baden-Würt­tem­berg Finan­ce Court, which dis­missed the cla­im (jud­ge­ment of 9 July 2024, ref. 9 K 86/24). The Fede­ral Finan­ce Court has now upheld this decis­i­on and dis­missed the claimant’s appeal as unfounded.

Reasons given by the Federal Fiscal Court

The court made it clear that anyo­ne who keeps accounts on a vol­un­t­a­ry basis and deter­mi­nes their pro­fit by com­pa­ring busi­ness assets is not entit­led to taxa­ti­on on an actu­al basis under sec­tion 20, first sen­tence, no. 3 of the Value Added Tax Act (UStG). This means that self-employ­ed pro­fes­sio­nals who keep accounts vol­un­t­a­ri­ly are trea­ted in the same way for VAT pur­po­ses as limi­t­ed com­pa­nies, such as a GmbH, which are requi­red to keep accounts and which are also unable to app­ly taxa­ti­on on an accru­al basis.

Important for prac­ti­cal pur­po­ses: Sim­ply main­tai­ning lists of out­stan­ding items is not suf­fi­ci­ent in its­elf to con­sti­tu­te vol­un­t­a­ry book­kee­ping. Only when the pro­fit for inco­me tax pur­po­ses is actual­ly deter­mi­ned by means of a com­pa­ri­son of busi­ness assets is this regard­ed as vol­un­t­a­ry book­kee­ping for the pur­po­ses of VAT law.

What does that mean in practice?

Free­lan­cers who have so far been using the ‘actu­al’ taxa­ti­on method and deter­mi­ning their pro­fit by com­pa­ring busi­ness assets should urgen­tly review their VAT situa­ti­on. They may need to switch to the ‘tar­get’ taxa­ti­on method, which could lead to increased liqui­di­ty requi­re­ments. The method used to deter­mi­ne pro­fits and whe­ther vol­un­t­a­ry book­kee­ping is actual­ly in place is often a mat­ter to be asses­sed on a case-by-case basis. Tax advice is stron­gly recom­men­ded in this regard.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this