Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Late payment surcharge despite tax refund: Federal Fiscal Court upholds tax office practice

Late payment surcharge despite tax refund: Federal Fiscal Court upholds tax office practice

Anyo­ne who sub­mits their tax return late must expect to pay a late fil­ing penal­ty. Accor­ding to a recent ruling by the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court, this appli­es even if the return ulti­m­ate­ly results in a refund. The ruling pri­ma­ri­ly affects busi­ness owners who are requi­red to sub­mit annu­al VAT returns.

What was the specific case about?

A tax­pay­er did not sub­mit his annu­al VAT return for 2020 until 30 Janu­ary 2023. The stan­dard dead­line had alre­a­dy pas­sed on 31 August 2022. Alt­hough the return show­ed a refund of just over 168 euros in favour of the clai­mant, the tax office nevert­hel­ess impo­sed a late fil­ing penal­ty of 125 euros. Reason: The dead­line had been excee­ded by seve­ral months, and the return for the pre­vious year, 2019, had also been sub­mit­ted late. The clai­mant con­tes­ted the surchar­ge but was unsuc­cessful, first befo­re the Saxon Finan­ce Court and sub­se­quent­ly befo­re the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court (BFH).

What did the Federal Fiscal Court rule?

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court dis­missed the claimant’s appeal as unfoun­ded (jud­ge­ment of 7 May 2026, ref. V R 26/24). The jud­ges made it clear that the ques­ti­on of whe­ther a late pay­ment surchar­ge is paya­ble can be divi­ded into two distinct scenarios.

  • Auto­ma­tic surchar­ge:In the case of annu­al tax returns, a sta­tu­to­ry late-fil­ing surchar­ge appli­es under cer­tain con­di­ti­ons, with no dis­cre­ti­on on the part of the tax office. Howe­ver, this does not app­ly if the tax asses­sed is zero or a nega­ti­ve amount, i.e. in the case of tax refunds.
  • Dis­cre­tio­na­ry award:In cases whe­re a refund is due, the tax office may nevert­hel­ess impo­se a late pay­ment penal­ty at its own dis­cre­ti­on. This is only ruled out if the delay is excusable.

In the pre­sent case, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) found no jus­ti­fia­ble grounds. Mere­ly refer­ring to a hea­vy workload and time cons­traints at the tax con­sul­tancy firm com­mis­sio­ned to hand­le the mat­ter was not suf­fi­ci­ent. The tax office had exer­cis­ed its dis­cre­ti­on cor­rect­ly and was entit­led to take into account not only the length of the delay but also the fact that the same situa­ti­on had occur­red the pre­vious year.

Focus on preventive effects

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) express­ly empha­sis­ed that the late fil­ing surchar­ge is pri­ma­ri­ly inten­ded to act as a deter­rent. It is desi­gned to encou­ra­ge tax­pay­ers and their advi­sers to take dead­lines serious­ly, even if the return does not ulti­m­ate­ly result in any addi­tio­nal tax lia­bi­li­ty. In the court’s view, the amount set at 25 euros for each month or part the­reof that the return was late was not disproportionate.

Fur­ther­mo­re, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) cla­ri­fied that month­ly or quar­ter­ly VAT returns and the annu­al return must be con­side­red sepa­ra­te­ly. Anyo­ne who sub­mits their month­ly or quar­ter­ly returns on time can­not the­r­e­fo­re auto­ma­ti­cal­ly assu­me that they will be excu­sed for sub­mit­ting their annu­al return late.

What does this mean for business owners and the self-employed?

For anyo­ne requi­red to sub­mit an annu­al VAT return, this ruling sends a clear mes­sa­ge: even if you end up recei­ving a refund from the tax office, this does not pro­tect you from a late fil­ing penal­ty. It is par­ti­cu­lar­ly ris­ky if you repea­ted­ly miss the dead­line. If in doubt, you should app­ly for an exten­si­on to the dead­line at an ear­ly stage or prio­ri­ti­se com­ple­ting the return. Anyo­ne who is unsu­re whe­ther a late fil­ing penal­ty has been lawful­ly impo­sed in their case should seek tax advice.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this