Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Contaminated sites on the property: When does the risk of remediation reduce the value of the property?

Con­ta­mi­na­ted sites on a plot of land do not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly redu­ce its value. The Saxon Finan­ce Court cla­ri­fies what mat­ters when it comes to land trans­fer tax. 
Contaminated sites on the property: When does the risk of remediation reduce the value of the property?

Contaminated sites on the property: When does the risk of remediation reduce the value of the property?

Anyo­ne who acqui­res shares in a com­pa­ny and ther­eby trig­gers what is known as a ‘share­hol­ding con­so­li­da­ti­on’ under the Land Trans­fer Tax Act must have the value of the land forming part of the company’s assets asses­sed sepa­ra­te­ly. The value of the land deter­mi­ned in this way forms the basis for asses­sing the land trans­fer tax. In a recent­ly published jud­ge­ment, the Saxon Finan­ce Court con­side­red whe­ther, and to what ext­ent, a plot of land con­ta­mi­na­ted with his­to­ri­cal pol­lu­ti­on may be valued at a lower mar­ket value.

The case: contamination of a contaminated site and a remediation order

In this spe­ci­fic case, a limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) owned a plot of land that was con­ta­mi­na­ted. The ground­wa­ter in the sur­roun­ding area was pol­lu­ted, and the dis­trict admi­nis­tra­ti­on issued a reme­dia­ti­on order which would also pass to any future owner. Howe­ver, the GmbH its­elf held cer­ti­fi­ca­tes of exemp­ti­on from con­ta­mi­na­ti­on lia­bi­li­ty, which had been issued by the rele­vant regio­nal coun­cil. This meant that the GmbH was exempt from the obli­ga­ti­on to reme­dia­te and did not have to bear the cos­ts itself.

The clai­mant sub­mit­ted seve­ral expert reports which con­cluded that sub­stan­ti­al reno­va­ti­on and safe­ty mea­su­res would be requi­red. The reports the­r­e­fo­re indi­ca­ted eit­her no mar­ket value or even a nega­ti­ve mar­ket value. The tax office did not accept this assess­ment and set a signi­fi­cant­ly hig­her pro­per­ty value.

The ruling: The actual circumstances as at the relevant date are decisive

The Saxon Finan­ce Court dis­missed the cla­im and ruled in favour of the tax office. The decisi­ve fac­tor was the ques­ti­on of what the actu­al cir­cum­s­tances were on the valua­ti­on date. The court stated:

  • The fair mar­ket value within the mea­ning of Sec­tion 198 of the Valua­ti­on Actcor­re­sponds to the mar­ket value as per Sec­tion 194 of the Buil­ding Codeas at the rele­vant valua­ti­on date.
  • As the owner was not obli­ged to car­ry out the refur­bish­ment under the exemp­ti­on noti­ces, she did not face any actu­al finan­cial risk at the rele­vant time.
  • Dis­counts for future, as yet unplan­ned invest­ments or spe­cu­la­ti­ve deve­lo­p­ments are not per­mit­ted under the stan­dar­di­sed valua­ti­on procedure.
  • The valua­tions initi­al­ly took as their basis a capi­ta­li­sed value that was hig­her than the tax authority’s valua­ti­on, and then deduc­ted theo­re­ti­cal­ly cal­cu­la­ted refur­bish­ment cos­ts. Accor­ding to the court, this method did not reflect the actu­al circumstances.

The court also empha­sis­ed that the mar­ket value repres­ents a notio­nal purcha­se pri­ce that would be rea­li­sed in the ordi­na­ry cour­se of busi­ness. In this con­text, it must be assu­med that, as at the valua­ti­on date, a hypo­the­ti­cal purcha­ser is in the same legal posi­ti­on as the ven­dor and is like­wi­se not bur­den­ed with refur­bish­ment cos­ts. Dis­counts appli­ed for a risk that did not actual­ly exist would distort the mar­ket value.

What does this mean in practice?

The jud­ge­ment high­lights how important it is, when valuing pro­per­ty, to draw a clear distinc­tion bet­ween actu­al encum­bran­ces and purely theo­re­ti­cal risks. Whe­re offi­ci­al exemp­ti­ons or simi­lar arran­ge­ments are in place, the­se can have a signi­fi­cant impact on the value. Valua­ti­on reports based on hypo­the­ti­cal cos­ts which, as at the valua­ti­on date, are not legal­ly paya­ble by the owner gene­ral­ly fail to con­vin­ce the tax courts.

Anyo­ne wis­hing to demons­tra­te a lower mar­ket value in simi­lar cir­cum­s­tances should have a review car­ri­ed out at an ear­ly stage to ascer­tain which lia­bi­li­ties were actual­ly legal­ly valid as at the valua­ti­on date. The jud­ge­ment is not yet final: an appeal has been lodged with the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court against the decis­i­on (Ref. II R 47/25). Busi­nesses and indi­vi­du­als affec­ted by simi­lar issues should keep an eye on fur­ther deve­lo­p­ments and seek expert advice.

Saxon Finan­ce Court, jud­ge­ment of 25 Sep­tem­ber 2025, Case No. 3 K 40/23

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this