Anyone who acquires shares in a company and thereby triggers what is known as a ‘shareholding consolidation’ under the Land Transfer Tax Act must have the value of the land forming part of the company’s assets assessed separately. The value of the land determined in this way forms the basis for assessing the land transfer tax. In a recently published judgement, the Saxon Finance Court considered whether, and to what extent, a plot of land contaminated with historical pollution may be valued at a lower market value.
The case: contamination of a contaminated site and a remediation order
In this specific case, a limited liability company (GmbH) owned a plot of land that was contaminated. The groundwater in the surrounding area was polluted, and the district administration issued a remediation order which would also pass to any future owner. However, the GmbH itself held certificates of exemption from contamination liability, which had been issued by the relevant regional council. This meant that the GmbH was exempt from the obligation to remediate and did not have to bear the costs itself.
The claimant submitted several expert reports which concluded that substantial renovation and safety measures would be required. The reports therefore indicated either no market value or even a negative market value. The tax office did not accept this assessment and set a significantly higher property value.
The ruling: The actual circumstances as at the relevant date are decisive
The Saxon Finance Court dismissed the claim and ruled in favour of the tax office. The decisive factor was the question of what the actual circumstances were on the valuation date. The court stated:
- The fair market value within the meaning of Section 198 of the Valuation Actcorresponds to the market value as per Section 194 of the Building Codeas at the relevant valuation date.
- As the owner was not obliged to carry out the refurbishment under the exemption notices, she did not face any actual financial risk at the relevant time.
- Discounts for future, as yet unplanned investments or speculative developments are not permitted under the standardised valuation procedure.
- The valuations initially took as their basis a capitalised value that was higher than the tax authority’s valuation, and then deducted theoretically calculated refurbishment costs. According to the court, this method did not reflect the actual circumstances.
The court also emphasised that the market value represents a notional purchase price that would be realised in the ordinary course of business. In this context, it must be assumed that, as at the valuation date, a hypothetical purchaser is in the same legal position as the vendor and is likewise not burdened with refurbishment costs. Discounts applied for a risk that did not actually exist would distort the market value.
What does this mean in practice?
The judgement highlights how important it is, when valuing property, to draw a clear distinction between actual encumbrances and purely theoretical risks. Where official exemptions or similar arrangements are in place, these can have a significant impact on the value. Valuation reports based on hypothetical costs which, as at the valuation date, are not legally payable by the owner generally fail to convince the tax courts.
Anyone wishing to demonstrate a lower market value in similar circumstances should have a review carried out at an early stage to ascertain which liabilities were actually legally valid as at the valuation date. The judgement is not yet final: an appeal has been lodged with the Federal Fiscal Court against the decision (Ref. II R 47/25). Businesses and individuals affected by similar issues should keep an eye on further developments and seek expert advice.
Saxon Finance Court, judgement of 25 September 2025, Case No. 3 K 40/23
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.