Anyone wishing to claim child benefit for a child undertaking a second course of education must ensure that the child does not engage in any harmful gainful employment for more than 20 hours per week. The Münster Finance Court has now clarified how periods of leave of absence on official business for civil servants are factored into this calculation, and in doing so has reached a nuanced decision that does not favour one side over the other across the board.
What had happened?
A taxpayer’s son had initially completed a dual study programme with the tax authorities and subsequently worked as a civil servant at the tax office. At the same time, he began a standard law degree in the winter semester of 2023. To enable him to study, his working hours were initially reduced to 70 per cent of the standard working hours, and from October 2024, as part of a North Rhine-Westphalia support programme, they were reduced to as little as 50 per cent.
The Family Benefits Office withdrew the child benefit. In its view, the son had already completed his initial training through the dual study programme and was now in full-time employment. They argued that the law degree was merely further training undertaken alongside his job. The father took legal action, arguing that the time off granted would reduce his relevant weekly working hours to below the critical threshold of 20 hours.
The decision of the Tax Court
The Münster Fiscal Court partially upheld the claim. The key finding: even for civil servants who do not have a traditional employment contract, the actual, individually tailored working hours are decisive. In practical terms, this means that occasion-specific time off, such as for exams or coursework, can reduce the number of working hours in the months in question.
In February, March and from June to September 2025, the son had been granted precisely such additional time off work. As a result, his actual working hours fell below 20 hours per week, which is why the court ruled that he was entitled to child benefit for those months. In the remaining months, including December 2024 and January, April and May 2025, the weekly working hours remained just above the threshold at 20.5 hours. Consequently, there was no entitlement for these periods.
Secondary training rather than initial training
Another key point of the judgement concerns the question of whether a law degree still counts as initial training. The Tax Court ruled that it does not. Whilst there is a substantive link between the Diploma in Public Finance programme and a law degree, the focus is clearly on long-term employment as a tax officer. A law degree serves the purpose of career advancement and must therefore be classified as further training. As a result, the stricter rules applicable to children undertaking further training apply, in particular the 20-hour limit on paid work.
What happens next?
The Finance Court has expressly allowed the appeal because the legal issue is of fundamental importance. The case is now pending before the Federal Finance Court under reference number III R 10/26. A final ruling by Germany’s highest tax court is therefore still pending.
What does this mean for parents?
Parents whose adult children are continuing their studies whilst working, following the completion of a vocational training programme or a dual study programme, should keep careful records of their working hours. Monthly records detailing any time off granted may be crucial. Anyone in a similar situation should seek tax advice, as the distinction between first and second degrees, as well as the calculation of the 20-hour limit, is complex.
Münster Regional Tax Court, judgment of 16 April 2026, Case No. 8 K 2927/25 Kg; appeal pending before the Federal Fiscal Court, Case No. III R 10/26.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.