Anyone who takes legal action against a property tax assessment notice and is required to submit a market value valuation report may, under certain circumstances, claim reimbursement of the costs incurred from the tax office. The Baden-Württemberg Finance Court ruled on this in a recent decision, thereby resolving a practical issue for property owners.
What was the case about?
A landowner had brought legal proceedings against the property tax valuation notice dated 1 January 2022. The tax office had set the property tax value at around 602,000 euros. The claimant considered this figure to be significantly too high and commissioned a market value report from the relevant valuation committee. The report determined the actual value of the land to be just 355,000 euros.
Both the tax office and the court had expressly requested the claimant in writing during the proceedings to submit such an expert report. The tax office eventually relented and amended the notice in line with the value determined in the expert report. The costs of the proceedings were ordered to be borne by the tax office.
Dispute over the costs of expert reports
The claimant subsequently applied for reimbursement of all his expenses, including the cost of the expert report, amounting to approximately 1,514 euros. The tax office disagreed: it pointed out that the taxpayer was legally obliged to provide evidence of the lower value and could not therefore pass on the costs of providing such evidence to the authorities.
The Tax Court took a different view. Under Section 139(1) of the Tax Court Rules (FGO), expenses are recoverable only if they were necessary for the proper pursuit of legal proceedings. The criterion here is the perspective of a reasonable party at the time the expenditure was incurred.
Court rules that costs are recoverable
The Tax Court found that the costs of the expert reports were indeed necessary in this case. Three factors were decisive:
- The tax office had already requested the claimant in writing, both during the administrative proceedings and again during the court proceedings, to submit an expert report.
- The court itself had issued a notice to that effect.
- The tax office subsequently included the value determined in the valuation report as the property tax value in the notice of amendment, thereby accepting the content of the valuation report.
In these circumstances, commissioning the expert report was not a voluntary measure, but a de facto unavoidable response to the requirements of the authorities and the court. The costs of around 1,514 euros are therefore recoverable.
What does this mean for property owners?
The new property tax reform has led to significant revaluations of land in many places. Many property owners consider the assessed property tax values to be too high. To successfully challenge these, tax offices and courts often require a valuation report as evidence. The ruling from Baden-Württemberg makes it clear that anyone who obtains such a report upon explicit request and is successful in their challenge does not have to bear the costs themselves.
The court also points out that legislative action is required. There are as yet no standardised and proportionate fees for such expert reports, which results in taxpayers facing varying levels of financial burden.
In individual cases, it is advisable to seek advice from a tax adviser or solicitor in order to assess the prospects of success of an appeal or legal action against a property tax assessment notice.
Baden-Württemberg Regional Court, Order of 5 May 2026, Case No. 8 KO 351/26
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.