Anyone who submits their tax return late must expect to pay a late filing penalty. According to a recent ruling by the Federal Fiscal Court, this applies even if the return ultimately results in a refund. The ruling primarily affects business owners who are required to submit annual VAT returns.
What was the specific case about?
A taxpayer did not submit his annual VAT return for 2020 until 30 January 2023. The standard deadline had already passed on 31 August 2022. Although the return showed a refund of just over 168 euros in favour of the claimant, the tax office nevertheless imposed a late filing penalty of 125 euros. Reason: The deadline had been exceeded by several months, and the return for the previous year, 2019, had also been submitted late. The claimant contested the surcharge but was unsuccessful, first before the Saxon Finance Court and subsequently before the Federal Finance Court (BFH).
What did the Federal Fiscal Court rule?
The Federal Fiscal Court dismissed the claimant’s appeal as unfounded (judgement of 7 May 2026, ref. V R 26/24). The judges made it clear that the question of whether a late payment surcharge is payable can be divided into two distinct scenarios.
- Automatic surcharge:In the case of annual tax returns, a statutory late-filing surcharge applies under certain conditions, with no discretion on the part of the tax office. However, this does not apply if the tax assessed is zero or a negative amount, i.e. in the case of tax refunds.
- Discretionary award:In cases where a refund is due, the tax office may nevertheless impose a late payment penalty at its own discretion. This is only ruled out if the delay is excusable.
In the present case, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) found no justifiable grounds. Merely referring to a heavy workload and time constraints at the tax consultancy firm commissioned to handle the matter was not sufficient. The tax office had exercised its discretion correctly and was entitled to take into account not only the length of the delay but also the fact that the same situation had occurred the previous year.
Focus on preventive effects
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) expressly emphasised that the late filing surcharge is primarily intended to act as a deterrent. It is designed to encourage taxpayers and their advisers to take deadlines seriously, even if the return does not ultimately result in any additional tax liability. In the court’s view, the amount set at 25 euros for each month or part thereof that the return was late was not disproportionate.
Furthermore, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) clarified that monthly or quarterly VAT returns and the annual return must be considered separately. Anyone who submits their monthly or quarterly returns on time cannot therefore automatically assume that they will be excused for submitting their annual return late.
What does this mean for business owners and the self-employed?
For anyone required to submit an annual VAT return, this ruling sends a clear message: even if you end up receiving a refund from the tax office, this does not protect you from a late filing penalty. It is particularly risky if you repeatedly miss the deadline. If in doubt, you should apply for an extension to the deadline at an early stage or prioritise completing the return. Anyone who is unsure whether a late filing penalty has been lawfully imposed in their case should seek tax advice.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.