Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Tax treatment of funds received upon the gift of limited partnership interests: Münster Finance Court clarifies key issue

Müns­ter Fis­cal Court: The trans­fer of share­hol­ders’ claims to a capi­tal reser­ve does not gene­ra­te new funds within the mea­ning of the Inhe­ri­tance Tax Act. 
Tax treatment of funds received upon the gift of limited partnership interests: Münster Finance Court clarifies key issue

Tax treatment of funds received upon the gift of limited partnership interests: Münster Finance Court clarifies key issue

Anyo­ne who gifts shares in a limi­t­ed part­ner­ship must, for the pur­po­ses of gift tax, con­sider, among­st other things, the con­cept of new fundsexami­ne. This rela­tes to a pro­vi­si­on in the Inhe­ri­tance and Gift Tax Act (ErbStG) which rest­ricts the scope of the so-cal­led busi­ness assets exemp­ti­on. The Müns­ter Finan­ce Court has now cla­ri­fied, in a ruling of prac­ti­cal rele­van­ce, the con­di­ti­ons under which such ‘new’ finan­cial resour­ces can ari­se in the first place.

What are young funds?

The Inhe­ri­tance Tax Act pro­vi­des for sub­stan­ti­al tax reli­ef on the trans­fer of busi­ness assets. Howe­ver, this reli­ef is not gran­ted wit­hout rest­ric­tion. Cer­tain assets, inclu­ding what are known as ‘recent funds’, are excluded from this reli­ef. Funds are regard­ed as ‘recent’ if they were recei­ved by the busi­ness less than two years befo­re the date of taxa­ti­on, i.e. if they were con­tri­bu­ted short­ly befo­re the gift was made. This is inten­ded to pre­vent cash or other funds from being deli­bera­te­ly trans­fer­red into busi­ness assets short­ly befo­re a trans­fer in order to bene­fit from the tax exemption.

The case: Shareholders’ claims transferred to the capital reserve

In this spe­ci­fic case, the donor and the donee were both limi­t­ed part­ners in a limi­t­ed part­ner­ship (KG). In Novem­ber 2018, both trans­fer­red their respec­ti­ve claims against the KG to the partnership’s joint assets. For accoun­ting pur­po­ses, this was recor­ded as an ent­ry in the capi­tal reser­ve held in joint owner­ship. A few months later, on 31 March 2019, the donor trans­fer­red his limi­t­ed part­ner­ship inte­rest to the clai­mant free of charge.

The rele­vant tax office took the view that the trans­fers in 2018 had resul­ted in new finan­cial resour­ces, and asses­sed their value at over 356,000 euros. This assess­ment would have signi­fi­cant­ly increased the gift tax liability.

The court finds that there was neither a withdrawal nor a deposit

The 3rd Cham­ber of the Müns­ter Finan­ce Court rejec­ted this view and set the value of the new funds at zero euros. The decisi­ve fac­tor was whe­ther the accoun­ting tran­sac­tions were, for inco­me tax pur­po­ses, to be trea­ted as Insertare to be regard­ed as such. This is becau­se the Act expli­cit­ly links the con­cept of ‘new funds’ to con­tri­bu­ti­ons and with­dra­wals for the pur­po­ses of inco­me tax.

Under the prin­ci­ples of inco­me tax law, the trans­fer of an asset from a limi­t­ed partner’s spe­cial busi­ness assets to the joint assets the sameIn a part­ner­ship, this does not con­sti­tu­te a with­dra­wal or a con­tri­bu­ti­on. Whilst the legal owner may chan­ge, in eco­no­mic terms the assets remain within the same part­ner­ship. The court also empha­sis­ed that the con­cept of ‘new funds’ is not equi­va­lent to that of ‘new admi­nis­tra­ti­ve assets’, which is why the rele­vant case law can­not be appli­ed automatically.

By way of fur­ther cla­ri­fi­ca­ti­on, the court sta­ted that even if a capi­tal con­tri­bu­ti­on were to be accept­ed, the sta­tu­to­ry off­set­ting requi­re­ment under sec­tion 13b(4)(5), second sen­tence, of the Inhe­ri­tance Tax Act (ErbStG) would have meant that, ulti­m­ate­ly, no new funds would have been generated.

What does this mean in practice?

The ruling is rele­vant to anyo­ne wis­hing to gift or bequeath shares in part­ner­ships. It demons­tra­tes that not every trans­fer of assets within a part­ner­ship auto­ma­ti­cal­ly results in ‘new funds’ that are dis­ad­van­ta­ge­ous for tax pur­po­ses. Howe­ver, the distinc­tion is com­plex and depends hea­vi­ly on the prin­ci­ples of inco­me tax law. As the Müns­ter Finan­ce Court has gran­ted lea­ve to appeal to the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court (BFH), the final word on this mat­ter has not yet been spoken.

Refe­rence num­ber:Müns­ter Regio­nal Court, Judgment of 16 July 2026, 3 K 682/24 EW

Anyo­ne plan­ning busi­ness suc­ces­si­on or a gift should have the tax impli­ca­ti­ons careful­ly asses­sed in advan­ce by a tax adviser.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this