Anyone who buys a plot of land from a local authority at below market price generally enters into a building obligation. In a recent judgement of 17 July 2026 (Case No. V ZR 153/25), the Federal Court of Justice has clarified the general principles governing what happens if construction does not take place and the purchaser requests more time.
What is a local labour model?
Under so-called ‘local residents’ schemes, local authorities sell building plots to local residents at reduced prices. In return, the buyer undertakes to build on the plot within a specified period and to use it for their own purposes. If they fail to fulfil this obligation, the local authority may buy back the plot, i.e. exercise its right of repurchase.
The case: Construction deadline has passed; the local authority wants the plot back
A Bavarian local authority had sold a plot of land in April 2019 at a price below market value. The buyer undertook to build a detached house by April 2023. Should she fail to do so, the local authority would have a right of repurchase for 15 years, which had to be exercised by registered post within six months of becoming aware of the breach.
Shortly before the construction deadline was due to expire, the purchaser requested a five-year extension in January 2023. The local authority rejected this in March 2023. In August 2023, she then exercised her right of repurchase and demanded the retransfer of the plot in return for repayment of the purchase price.
The Regional Court and the Higher Regional Court dismissed the local authority’s claim. Their reasoning was that the six-month period had already begun upon receipt of the application for an extension in January 2023, and that the exercise of the right in August 2023 had therefore taken place too late.
The Federal Court of Justice rules in favour of the local authority
The Federal Court of Justice took a different view and made it clear that the time limit for exercising the right of repurchase does not begin until the local authority has rejected the application for an extension, i.e. on 9 March 2023 at the earliest. This is because local authorities are bound by public law and must carefully consider whether to grant such a request. They require sufficient time to make this discretionary decision. It is only after the request has been rejected that it is definitively established that the construction deadline cannot be met.
As the local authority exercised its right of repurchase on 4 August 2023, this fell within the six-month period. The right to re-transfer therefore existed.
No right of withdrawal in addition to the right of repurchase
However, the Federal Court of Justice did not permit a further withdrawal from the purchase contract. The obligation to build under the ‘local resident’ model is not an enforceable primary obligation, but rather a so-called ‘duty’. This means that, whilst the purchaser is not legally obliged to build the house, she risks losing the plot of land if she fails to do so. If a right of repurchase has been agreed, the local authority is restricted to this and may not additionally withdraw from the contract.
What does this mean for buyers and local authorities?
For private individuals purchasing a plot of land under a local residents’ scheme, this ruling sends an important message: the obligation to build must be taken seriously. A favourable purchase price is conditional upon development taking place in a timely manner. Anyone who fails to meet the deadline and applies for an extension runs the risk that the local authority will exercise its right of repurchase as soon as it rejects the application.
For local authorities, the ruling provides legal certainty as to when the period for exercising this right begins and how discretionary decisions regarding an extension of this period should be interpreted. Anyone who, as a property buyer, finds themselves in a similar situation, or who wishes to act on behalf of a local authority, should seek legal advice on a case-by-case basis.
Source: Haufe: Property
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.