People who visit relatives in need of care and travel long distances to do so often hope to be able to claim these costs for tax purposes. The Münster Finance Court has now once again clarified that such travel costs are generally not deductible as extraordinary expenses under Section 33 of the Income Tax Act (EStG). The court has thus confirmed its long-standing line of case law.
The case: a long-running dispute over around 6,700 euros
A married couple had been caring for their severely disabled mother and mother-in-law, who lived a long way away, for many years. Since 2015, the claimants had been disputing before the Münster Finance Court whether their journeys to visit their mother should be taken into account for tax purposes. For the tax year in question, 2021, they claimed travel expenses, parking fees and postage costs totalling around 13,000 euros. The amount actually in dispute ultimately amounted to around 6,700 euros.
The tax office rejected the deduction and took into account only the flat-rate care allowance under Section 33b(6) of the Income Tax Act. The couple lodged a further appeal against this decision.
The absence of inevitability as a key argument
Extraordinary expenses under section 33 of the Income Tax Act (EStG) require that the expenses be extraordinary, unavoidable and of a greater amount than those incurred by comparable taxpayers. The court ruled that the criterion of unavoidability was not met. Anyone living a long way from a person in need of care is not morally obliged to provide the care themselves rather than entrusting it to professional carers. The fact that the mother preferred care to be provided by family members does not alter this.
New rules on the flat-rate care allowance are of no help
The claimants also sought to use the revised version of the flat-rate care allowance, which came into force in 2021, as a basis for their case. Since 2021, the flat-rate allowance has also been available to carers who do not receive any income for providing care and who do not look after the person in need of care in their own household. The claimants argued that this legislative change now also allows for the deduction of higher costs that have actually been substantiated, in accordance with Section 33 of the Income Tax Act (EStG).
The court did not accept this argument. The new legislation relates exclusively to the conditions for the lump-sum allowance itself, but not to the general conditions for extraordinary financial burdens. Furthermore, the care allowance also requires that the underlying expenses be unavoidable. As this was lacking in this case, the tax office might not have been entitled to grant the lump sum either. However, the court was able to leave this question open because a worsening of the plaintiffs’ position is not permitted in tax court proceedings – the so-called ‘prohibition on worsening the position’.
What does this mean for family carers?
The judgement shows that the tax treatment of travel costs incurred in providing care depends on the specific circumstances and is difficult to determine in many situations. Anyone who actually incurs substantial expenses for the care of relatives should have their case assessed to determine whether ‘inevitability’ can be established in their specific circumstances – for example, where professional care is objectively impossible or unreasonable. In such cases, the flat-rate care allowance usually remains the most practical alternative.
It is advisable to seek personalised tax advice in order to make the most of all available tax deductions in each specific case.
Münster Regional Court, judgement of 26 June 2026, case number 4 K 2261/25 E
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.