Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Travel costs incurred whilst caring for relatives: Not deductible as an exceptional financial burden

Travel costs incurred whilst caring for relatives: Not deductible as an exceptional financial burden

Peo­p­le who visit rela­ti­ves in need of care and tra­vel long distances to do so often hope to be able to cla­im the­se cos­ts for tax pur­po­ses. The Müns­ter Finan­ce Court has now once again cla­ri­fied that such tra­vel cos­ts are gene­ral­ly not deduc­ti­ble as extra­or­di­na­ry expen­ses under Sec­tion 33 of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG). The court has thus con­firm­ed its long-stan­ding line of case law.

The case: a long-running dispute over around 6,700 euros

A mar­ried cou­ple had been caring for their sever­ely dis­ab­led mother and mother-in-law, who lived a long way away, for many years. Sin­ce 2015, the clai­mants had been dis­pu­ting befo­re the Müns­ter Finan­ce Court whe­ther their jour­neys to visit their mother should be taken into account for tax pur­po­ses. For the tax year in ques­ti­on, 2021, they clai­med tra­vel expen­ses, par­king fees and post­age cos­ts total­ling around 13,000 euros. The amount actual­ly in dis­pu­te ulti­m­ate­ly amoun­ted to around 6,700 euros.

The tax office rejec­ted the deduc­tion and took into account only the flat-rate care allo­wan­ce under Sec­tion 33b(6) of the Inco­me Tax Act. The cou­ple lodged a fur­ther appeal against this decision.

The absence of inevitability as a key argument

Extra­or­di­na­ry expen­ses under sec­tion 33 of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG) requi­re that the expen­ses be extra­or­di­na­ry, unavo­ida­ble and of a grea­ter amount than tho­se incur­red by com­pa­ra­ble tax­pay­ers. The court ruled that the cri­ter­ion of unavo­ida­bili­ty was not met. Anyo­ne living a long way from a per­son in need of care is not moral­ly obli­ged to pro­vi­de the care them­sel­ves rather than ent­rus­ting it to pro­fes­sio­nal carers. The fact that the mother pre­fer­red care to be pro­vi­ded by fami­ly mem­bers does not alter this.

New rules on the flat-rate care allowance are of no help

The clai­mants also sought to use the revi­sed ver­si­on of the flat-rate care allo­wan­ce, which came into force in 2021, as a basis for their case. Sin­ce 2021, the flat-rate allo­wan­ce has also been available to carers who do not recei­ve any inco­me for pro­vi­ding care and who do not look after the per­son in need of care in their own house­hold. The clai­mants argued that this legis­la­ti­ve chan­ge now also allows for the deduc­tion of hig­her cos­ts that have actual­ly been sub­stan­tia­ted, in accordance with Sec­tion 33 of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG).

The court did not accept this argu­ment. The new legis­la­ti­on rela­tes exclu­si­ve­ly to the con­di­ti­ons for the lump-sum allo­wan­ce its­elf, but not to the gene­ral con­di­ti­ons for extra­or­di­na­ry finan­cial bur­dens. Fur­ther­mo­re, the care allo­wan­ce also requi­res that the under­ly­ing expen­ses be unavo­ida­ble. As this was lack­ing in this case, the tax office might not have been entit­led to grant the lump sum eit­her. Howe­ver, the court was able to lea­ve this ques­ti­on open becau­se a wor­sening of the plain­ti­ffs’ posi­ti­on is not per­mit­ted in tax court pro­cee­dings – the so-cal­led ‘pro­hi­bi­ti­on on wor­sening the position’.

What does this mean for family carers?

The jud­ge­ment shows that the tax tre­at­ment of tra­vel cos­ts incur­red in pro­vi­ding care depends on the spe­ci­fic cir­cum­s­tances and is dif­fi­cult to deter­mi­ne in many situa­tions. Anyo­ne who actual­ly incurs sub­stan­ti­al expen­ses for the care of rela­ti­ves should have their case asses­sed to deter­mi­ne whe­ther ‘ine­vi­ta­bi­li­ty’ can be estab­lished in their spe­ci­fic cir­cum­s­tances – for exam­p­le, whe­re pro­fes­sio­nal care is objec­tively impos­si­ble or unre­asonable. In such cases, the flat-rate care allo­wan­ce usual­ly remains the most prac­ti­cal alternative.

It is advi­sa­ble to seek per­so­na­li­sed tax advice in order to make the most of all available tax deduc­tions in each spe­ci­fic case.

Müns­ter Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 26 June 2026, case num­ber 4 K 2261/25 E

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this