Anyone lodging an appeal against a reduction in their coronavirus bridging support should be aware that the statement of grounds for the appeal is the last real opportunity to put forward new arguments and figures. Anything omitted from the appeal is highly likely to be disregarded in subsequent legal proceedings. The Karlsruhe Administrative Court made this clear in a judgement dated 7 July 2026 (Case No. 8 K 12012/25).
What had happened?
A limited liability company (GmbH) in the plant engineering sector had applied for and been granted ‘Bridging Aid I’ of 50,000 euros for August 2020. However, the business premises did not belong to the GmbH itself, but were jointly owned by the sole shareholder and his wife. The GmbH paid them monthly rent of around 31,533 euros.
It was precisely these rental costs that the relevant L‑Bank struck out entirely in its final decision. Its reasoning was that, according to the FAQs on Bridging Aid I, payments within a group of companies are not eligible for funding. Instead of 50,000 euros, only around 32,930 euros remained; the rest had to be repaid.
Amendments to an appeal were admissible
During the appeal proceedings, the GmbH not only sought to challenge the assumption of a group, but also, in the alternative, claimed further fixed costs, specifically property tax and interest expenses. L‑Bank completely disregarded this argument and rejected the appeal. It argued that no further changes were possible once the final assessment notice had been issued.
The Karlsruhe Administrative Court took a different view. According to established case law, the relevant point in time for assessing a discretionary decision is the date on which the notice of decision on the appeal is issued, not that of the original decision. This means that anyone who specifies new fixed costs or amends details during the appeal proceedings compels the authority to address these issues. If it fails to do so, this constitutes a so-called failure to exercise discretion – that is, a procedural error which may lead to the decision being set aside.
The court also made it clear that, in such cases, the authority must itself request the third party carrying out the audit – that is, the tax adviser – to submit a corrected final statement. The technical closure of the portal does not relieve the authority of this obligation.
Too late is too late: two proposals have failed
At the same time, the judgement highlights the downside. Rent-related service charges amounting to 383 euros had been inadvertently entered under the wrong fixed-cost heading. This error only came to light during the oral hearing, i.e. after the appeal proceedings. The court did not allow the correction to be made. The deadline had passed, and the claim was therefore definitively lost.
A further interest charge of 5.20 euros had been claimed in the statement of defence for the wrong month. Here, too, the statement of claim was of no avail.
Criticism of the network assumption
The court itself accepted L‑Bank’s practice of automatically inferring the existence of a group of companies from family ties between the landlord and a shareholder in a limited liability company. This arrangement is legally open to challenge. In a judgement of 27 February 2014 (Case C‑110/13), the European Court of Justice clarified that joint action requires actual coordination and cannot be inferred solely from family relationships.
The separation of business assets and property is a common and legally recognised arrangement in Germany. In principle, it has nothing to do with the question of whether COVID-19-related losses of turnover are eligible for support. Anyone facing the removal of their group status should check whether the landlord’s building expenses can, as an alternative, be treated as fixed costs in accordance with the Supplementary Guidelines issued by the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs on 19 July 2024.
What does that mean in practice?
The following applies to all ongoing appeal proceedings concerning final COVID-19 settlement statements: the grounds for the appeal must be complete. Any fixed-cost items yet to be claimed, any incorrect allocations and any substantive corrections must be specified there at the latest. It is strongly recommended that you seek legal or tax advice throughout the appeal process, as the sources of error lie in the details and the financial implications can be significant.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.