Anyone who runs a GmbH or is a shareholder in one knows that issuing a correct invitation to a shareholders’ meeting is no small matter. Errors in the formal requirements can result in resolutions passed being open to challenge or even void. The Higher Regional Court of Celle has now, in a recent judgement, provided important clarifications that will make the process considerably easier in practice.
What was the case about?
A minority shareholder in a GmbH held a 49 per cent stake. At a shareholders’ meeting on 11 September 2023, resolutions were passed which, amongst other things, led to the dismissal of a managing director. The shareholder refused to accept this and brought an action to have these resolutions declared null and void.
Her main argument was that the invitations to the meetings were formally flawed. Section 51(1) of the Limited Liability Companies Act (GmbHG) stipulates that invitations to shareholders’ meetings must be sent by registered post. The articles of association of this limited liability company merely required the invitations to be in writing, without expressly mentioning registered post. The shareholder was of the opinion that this did not alter the statutory obligation to use registered post. Furthermore, she claimed she had not received the invitation to the second meeting at all.
The Hanover Regional Court initially ruled in her favour. The company lodged an appeal and was successful before the Higher Regional Court of Celle.
An overview of the decision of the Higher Regional Court of Celle
The Higher Regional Court of Celle dismissed the claim and, in doing so, clarified the following (judgement of 9 July 2025, ref. 9 U 64/24):
- Registered post is not required:The statutory requirement to send invitations by registered post applies only if the articles of association do not contain any provision to the contrary. If the articles of association merely stipulate that the notice must be in writing, the requirement for registered post is effectively waived. In that case, a simple letter signed by hand is sufficient.
- Postage is sufficient; no proof of delivery is required:The invitation is not a declaration of intent requiring acknowledgement of receipt, but rather an internal procedural act within the company. Consequently, the general rules on service set out in Section 130 of the German Civil Code (BGB) do not apply. The company need only prove that the invitation was sent in good time. Whether it actually reached the shareholder is at the shareholder’s own risk.
- No breach of the duty of loyalty:It is true that the invitation to the second meeting had not reached the claimant. However, the company only became aware of this on the day of the meeting itself. In the court’s view, there was no obligation under these circumstances to cancel the meeting at short notice or to make active enquiries in advance.
What does this mean in practice?
This ruling poses a significant risk to limited liability companies (GmbHs) and their shareholders. Until now, it was common practice to send invitations by registered post as a precaution, so as to be able to prove delivery in the event of a dispute. Although this remains advisable following this ruling, it is not legally mandatory, provided that the articles of association do not stipulate a more stringent form.
The court’s comment on the requirement for the invitation to be in writing is also interesting: if the articles of association merely stipulate that the invitation must be in writing, it may even be sent by email, text message or WhatsApp.
All limited liability companies (GmbHs) are advised to review their articles of association and clearly set out the procedure for issuing invitations. In the case of important resolutions, such as the removal of a managing director, sending a registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt remains a reliable way of avoiding disputes later on. Anyone who is unsure about the wording in the articles of association should seek legal advice.
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.