Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Celle Higher Regional Court: An invitation to a GmbH shareholders’ meeting sent by ordinary post is sufficient

Cel­le Hig­her Regio­nal Court: A simp­le writ­ten-form clau­se in the GmbH’s artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on super­se­des the sta­tu­to­ry requi­re­ment for regis­tered post in the case of share­hol­ders’ meetings. 
Celle Higher Regional Court: An invitation to a GmbH shareholders’ meeting sent by ordinary post is sufficient

Celle Higher Regional Court: An invitation to a GmbH shareholders’ meeting sent by ordinary post is sufficient

Anyo­ne who runs a GmbH or is a share­hol­der in one knows that issuing a cor­rect invi­ta­ti­on to a share­hol­ders’ mee­ting is no small mat­ter. Errors in the for­mal requi­re­ments can result in reso­lu­ti­ons pas­sed being open to chall­enge or even void. The Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Cel­le has now, in a recent jud­ge­ment, pro­vi­ded important cla­ri­fi­ca­ti­ons that will make the pro­cess con­sider­a­b­ly easier in practice.

What was the case about?

A mino­ri­ty share­hol­der in a GmbH held a 49 per cent sta­ke. At a share­hol­ders’ mee­ting on 11 Sep­tem­ber 2023, reso­lu­ti­ons were pas­sed which, among­st other things, led to the dis­mis­sal of a mana­ging direc­tor. The share­hol­der refu­sed to accept this and brought an action to have the­se reso­lu­ti­ons declared null and void.

Her main argu­ment was that the invi­ta­ti­ons to the mee­tings were for­mal­ly fla­wed. Sec­tion 51(1) of the Limi­t­ed Lia­bi­li­ty Com­pa­nies Act (GmbHG) sti­pu­la­tes that invi­ta­ti­ons to share­hol­ders’ mee­tings must be sent by regis­tered post. The artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on of this limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny mere­ly requi­red the invi­ta­ti­ons to be in wri­ting, wit­hout express­ly men­tio­ning regis­tered post. The share­hol­der was of the opi­ni­on that this did not alter the sta­tu­to­ry obli­ga­ti­on to use regis­tered post. Fur­ther­mo­re, she clai­med she had not recei­ved the invi­ta­ti­on to the second mee­ting at all.

The Hano­ver Regio­nal Court initi­al­ly ruled in her favour. The com­pa­ny lodged an appeal and was suc­cessful befo­re the Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Celle.

An overview of the decision of the Higher Regional Court of Celle

The Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Cel­le dis­missed the cla­im and, in doing so, cla­ri­fied the fol­lo­wing (jud­ge­ment of 9 July 2025, ref. 9 U 64/24):

  • Regis­tered post is not requi­red:The sta­tu­to­ry requi­re­ment to send invi­ta­ti­ons by regis­tered post appli­es only if the artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on do not con­tain any pro­vi­si­on to the con­tra­ry. If the artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on mere­ly sti­pu­la­te that the noti­ce must be in wri­ting, the requi­re­ment for regis­tered post is effec­tively wai­ved. In that case, a simp­le let­ter signed by hand is sufficient.
  • Post­age is suf­fi­ci­ent; no pro­of of deli­very is requi­red:The invi­ta­ti­on is not a decla­ra­ti­on of intent requi­ring ack­now­led­ge­ment of receipt, but rather an inter­nal pro­ce­du­ral act within the com­pa­ny. Con­se­quent­ly, the gene­ral rules on ser­vice set out in Sec­tion 130 of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB) do not app­ly. The com­pa­ny need only pro­ve that the invi­ta­ti­on was sent in good time. Whe­ther it actual­ly rea­ched the share­hol­der is at the shareholder’s own risk.
  • No breach of the duty of loyal­ty:It is true that the invi­ta­ti­on to the second mee­ting had not rea­ched the clai­mant. Howe­ver, the com­pa­ny only beca­me awa­re of this on the day of the mee­ting its­elf. In the court’s view, the­re was no obli­ga­ti­on under the­se cir­cum­s­tances to can­cel the mee­ting at short noti­ce or to make acti­ve enqui­ries in advance.

What does this mean in practice?

This ruling poses a signi­fi­cant risk to limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­nies (GmbHs) and their share­hol­ders. Until now, it was com­mon prac­ti­ce to send invi­ta­ti­ons by regis­tered post as a pre­cau­ti­on, so as to be able to pro­ve deli­very in the event of a dis­pu­te. Alt­hough this remains advi­sa­ble fol­lo­wing this ruling, it is not legal­ly man­da­to­ry, pro­vi­ded that the artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on do not sti­pu­la­te a more strin­gent form.

The court’s com­ment on the requi­re­ment for the invi­ta­ti­on to be in wri­ting is also inte­res­t­ing: if the artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on mere­ly sti­pu­la­te that the invi­ta­ti­on must be in wri­ting, it may even be sent by email, text mes­sa­ge or WhatsApp.

All limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­nies (GmbHs) are advi­sed to review their artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on and cle­ar­ly set out the pro­ce­du­re for issuing invi­ta­ti­ons. In the case of important reso­lu­ti­ons, such as the rem­oval of a mana­ging direc­tor, sen­ding a regis­tered let­ter with ack­now­led­ge­ment of receipt remains a relia­ble way of avo­i­ding dis­pu­tes later on. Anyo­ne who is unsu­re about the wor­ding in the artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on should seek legal advice.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this