Anyone who receives a co-ownership share in a plot of land as a gift must pay gift tax on the full calculated share of the property’s value. According to a ruling by the Federal Fiscal Court, a reduction on the grounds that the share is difficult to sell or is worth less on the market is not permitted. The Federal Fiscal Court clarified this in its ruling of 18 January 2016 (Ref. II B 29/15), which was subsequently designated for official publication.
What are co-ownership shares?
If a plot of land is jointly owned by several people, each of them holds what is known as a fractional share or a notional share of co-ownership. This may be the case, for example, with an inherited family plot of land that has been divided amongst several siblings. If such a share is gifted, the question arises as to how it should be valued for gift tax purposes.
In the case in question, a taxpayer had argued that his co-ownership share was worth less than his notional share of the entire property because he could not sell it separately. On the open market, an isolated co-ownership share could only be sold with difficulty or at a discount. He therefore concluded that a lower value should be applied for the purposes of gift tax.
BFH: Impairment cannot be taken into account
The Federal Fiscal Court did not accept this line of argument. The basis for this is the Valuation Act, which defines the so-called ‘market value’ in Section 9(2). This is based on the price that would be realised in the ordinary course of business. The decisive factor here is what a buyer would pay for the entire property, not what a single co-ownership share could fetch in isolation.
The sale of a single co-ownership share without the involvement of the other owners is precisely not in line with normal commercial practice. Such transactions are unusual and are therefore excluded from the valuation. The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) had already clarified this issue in principle in a ruling of 22 July 2005 (Ref. II B 58/05), and the current ruling confirms this line of reasoning.
The following therefore applies in respect of gift tax: the property is assessed as a single unit, and the share attributable to the recipient is calculated accordingly. It is not permissible to provide separate evidence of a lower market value solely on the grounds that the property cannot be sold as a separate unit.
What does this mean in practice for gifts?
For private individuals who wish to gift a plot of land or a share in it to a family member, this decision has significant consequences. It is not possible to reduce the gift tax liability by arguing that the property is of limited marketability. The value is always based on the proportionate market value of the entire property.
- Property valuation is carried out on a uniform basis for the entire property.
- The co-ownership share is calculated as a proportion of the total value.
- Discounts cannot be applied on the grounds that the goods cannot be sold independently.
- The decision applies to gifts and, by extension, to cases of inheritance.
Anyone wishing to transfer land or co-ownership shares by way of a gift or inheritance should have the tax implications carefully assessed in advance. In individual cases, tax allowances and choosing the right timing can have a significant impact on the tax liability. It is advisable to seek tax advice in such circumstances.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.