Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Co-ownership share in the property: No valuation discount for gift tax purposes

BFH: Anyo­ne who recei­ves a co-owner­ship share in a plot of land as a gift can­not cla­im a valua­ti­on dis­count on the grounds of poor marketability. 
Co-ownership share in the property: No valuation discount for gift tax purposes

Co-ownership share in the property: No valuation discount for gift tax purposes

Anyo­ne who recei­ves a co-owner­ship share in a plot of land as a gift must pay gift tax on the full cal­cu­la­ted share of the property’s value. Accor­ding to a ruling by the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court, a reduc­tion on the grounds that the share is dif­fi­cult to sell or is worth less on the mar­ket is not per­mit­ted. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court cla­ri­fied this in its ruling of 18 Janu­ary 2016 (Ref. II B 29/15), which was sub­se­quent­ly desi­gna­ted for offi­ci­al publication.

What are co-ownership shares?

If a plot of land is joint­ly owned by seve­ral peo­p­le, each of them holds what is known as a frac­tion­al share or a notio­nal share of co-owner­ship. This may be the case, for exam­p­le, with an inhe­ri­ted fami­ly plot of land that has been divi­ded among­st seve­ral siblings. If such a share is gifted, the ques­ti­on ari­ses as to how it should be valued for gift tax purposes.

In the case in ques­ti­on, a tax­pay­er had argued that his co-owner­ship share was worth less than his notio­nal share of the enti­re pro­per­ty becau­se he could not sell it sepa­ra­te­ly. On the open mar­ket, an iso­la­ted co-owner­ship share could only be sold with dif­fi­cul­ty or at a dis­count. He the­r­e­fo­re con­cluded that a lower value should be appli­ed for the pur­po­ses of gift tax.

BFH: Impairment cannot be taken into account

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court did not accept this line of argu­ment. The basis for this is the Valua­ti­on Act, which defi­nes the so-cal­led ‘mar­ket value’ in Sec­tion 9(2). This is based on the pri­ce that would be rea­li­sed in the ordi­na­ry cour­se of busi­ness. The decisi­ve fac­tor here is what a buy­er would pay for the enti­re pro­per­ty, not what a sin­gle co-owner­ship share could fetch in isolation.

The sale of a sin­gle co-owner­ship share wit­hout the invol­vement of the other owners is pre­cis­e­ly not in line with nor­mal com­mer­cial prac­ti­ce. Such tran­sac­tions are unu­su­al and are the­r­e­fo­re excluded from the valua­ti­on. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) had alre­a­dy cla­ri­fied this issue in prin­ci­ple in a ruling of 22 July 2005 (Ref. II B 58/05), and the cur­rent ruling con­firms this line of reasoning.

The fol­lo­wing the­r­e­fo­re appli­es in respect of gift tax: the pro­per­ty is asses­sed as a sin­gle unit, and the share attri­bu­ta­ble to the reci­pi­ent is cal­cu­la­ted accor­din­gly. It is not per­mis­si­ble to pro­vi­de sepa­ra­te evi­dence of a lower mar­ket value sole­ly on the grounds that the pro­per­ty can­not be sold as a sepa­ra­te unit.

What does this mean in practice for gifts?

For pri­va­te indi­vi­du­als who wish to gift a plot of land or a share in it to a fami­ly mem­ber, this decis­i­on has signi­fi­cant con­se­quen­ces. It is not pos­si­ble to redu­ce the gift tax lia­bi­li­ty by arguing that the pro­per­ty is of limi­t­ed mar­ke­ta­bi­li­ty. The value is always based on the pro­por­tio­na­te mar­ket value of the enti­re property.

  • Pro­per­ty valua­ti­on is car­ri­ed out on a uni­form basis for the enti­re property.
  • The co-owner­ship share is cal­cu­la­ted as a pro­por­ti­on of the total value.
  • Dis­counts can­not be appli­ed on the grounds that the goods can­not be sold independently.
  • The decis­i­on appli­es to gifts and, by exten­si­on, to cases of inheritance.

Anyo­ne wis­hing to trans­fer land or co-owner­ship shares by way of a gift or inhe­ri­tance should have the tax impli­ca­ti­ons careful­ly asses­sed in advan­ce. In indi­vi­du­al cases, tax allo­wan­ces and choo­sing the right timing can have a signi­fi­cant impact on the tax lia­bi­li­ty. It is advi­sa­ble to seek tax advice in such circumstances.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this