Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Child benefit despite civil servant status: When periods of leave fall below the 20-hour limit

Müns­ter Regio­nal Court: Exemp­ti­ons from writ­ten exami­na­ti­ons can bring civil ser­vants below the 20-hour thres­hold and ensu­re they recei­ve child benefit. 
Child benefit despite civil servant status: When periods of leave fall below the 20-hour limit

Child benefit despite civil servant status: When periods of leave fall below the 20-hour limit

Anyo­ne wis­hing to cla­im child bene­fit for a child under­ta­king a second cour­se of edu­ca­ti­on must ensu­re that the child does not enga­ge in any harmful gain­ful employ­ment for more than 20 hours per week. The Müns­ter Finan­ce Court has now cla­ri­fied how peri­ods of lea­ve of absence on offi­ci­al busi­ness for civil ser­vants are fac­to­red into this cal­cu­la­ti­on, and in doing so has rea­ched a nuan­ced decis­i­on that does not favour one side over the other across the board.

What had happened?

A taxpayer’s son had initi­al­ly com­ple­ted a dual stu­dy pro­gram­me with the tax aut­ho­ri­ties and sub­se­quent­ly work­ed as a civil ser­vant at the tax office. At the same time, he began a stan­dard law degree in the win­ter semes­ter of 2023. To enable him to stu­dy, his working hours were initi­al­ly redu­ced to 70 per cent of the stan­dard working hours, and from Octo­ber 2024, as part of a North Rhi­ne-West­pha­lia sup­port pro­gram­me, they were redu­ced to as litt­le as 50 per cent.

The Fami­ly Bene­fits Office with­drew the child bene­fit. In its view, the son had alre­a­dy com­ple­ted his initi­al trai­ning through the dual stu­dy pro­gram­me and was now in full-time employ­ment. They argued that the law degree was mere­ly fur­ther trai­ning under­ta­ken along­side his job. The father took legal action, arguing that the time off gran­ted would redu­ce his rele­vant weekly working hours to below the cri­ti­cal thres­hold of 20 hours.

The decision of the Tax Court

The Müns­ter Fis­cal Court par­ti­al­ly upheld the cla­im. The key fin­ding: even for civil ser­vants who do not have a tra­di­tio­nal employ­ment con­tract, the actu­al, indi­vi­du­al­ly tail­o­red working hours are decisi­ve. In prac­ti­cal terms, this means that occa­si­on-spe­ci­fic time off, such as for exams or cour­se­work, can redu­ce the num­ber of working hours in the months in question.

In Febru­ary, March and from June to Sep­tem­ber 2025, the son had been gran­ted pre­cis­e­ly such addi­tio­nal time off work. As a result, his actu­al working hours fell below 20 hours per week, which is why the court ruled that he was entit­led to child bene­fit for tho­se months. In the remai­ning months, inclu­ding Decem­ber 2024 and Janu­ary, April and May 2025, the weekly working hours remain­ed just abo­ve the thres­hold at 20.5 hours. Con­se­quent­ly, the­re was no entit­le­ment for the­se periods.

Secondary training rather than initial training

Ano­ther key point of the jud­ge­ment con­cerns the ques­ti­on of whe­ther a law degree still counts as initi­al trai­ning. The Tax Court ruled that it does not. Whilst the­re is a sub­stan­ti­ve link bet­ween the Diplo­ma in Public Finan­ce pro­gram­me and a law degree, the focus is cle­ar­ly on long-term employ­ment as a tax offi­cer. A law degree ser­ves the pur­po­se of care­er advance­ment and must the­r­e­fo­re be clas­si­fied as fur­ther trai­ning. As a result, the stric­ter rules appli­ca­ble to child­ren under­ta­king fur­ther trai­ning app­ly, in par­ti­cu­lar the 20-hour limit on paid work.

What happens next?

The Finan­ce Court has express­ly allo­wed the appeal becau­se the legal issue is of fun­da­men­tal importance. The case is now pen­ding befo­re the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court under refe­rence num­ber III R 10/26. A final ruling by Germany’s hig­hest tax court is the­r­e­fo­re still pending.

What does this mean for parents?

Par­ents who­se adult child­ren are con­ti­nuing their stu­dies whilst working, fol­lo­wing the com­ple­ti­on of a voca­tio­nal trai­ning pro­gram­me or a dual stu­dy pro­gram­me, should keep careful records of their working hours. Month­ly records detail­ing any time off gran­ted may be cru­cial. Anyo­ne in a simi­lar situa­ti­on should seek tax advice, as the distinc­tion bet­ween first and second degrees, as well as the cal­cu­la­ti­on of the 20-hour limit, is complex.

Müns­ter Regio­nal Tax Court, judgment of 16 April 2026, Case No. 8 K 2927/25 Kg; appeal pen­ding befo­re the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court, Case No. III R 10/26.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this