Anyone with a Riester building society savings scheme has often been paying an annual fee to their building society for years. The Federal Court of Justice has now ruled that such fees are unlawful. In many cases, affected consumers can claim back any excess amounts paid.
What was it about?
The Federation of German Consumer Organisations (vzbv) brought a legal action against the general terms and conditions of a building society. The building society had included a clause in its contracts providing for an annual administration fee. Until early 2022, this was 15 euros per year; thereafter, it was 24 euros for new contracts. The clause also allowed the building society to adjust the fee in the event of rising administrative costs.
The Regional Court had initially dismissed the claim, and the Court of Appeal upheld that decision. However, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) ruled entirely in favour of the vzbv on appeal.
Why are the clauses invalid?
The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) classified the remuneration clauses as so-called ancillary price agreements. These are provisions which do not determine the main price of a contract, but rather govern ancillary costs or additional remuneration. Such clauses are subject to the scrutiny of standard terms and conditions under Section 307 of the German Civil Code.
The building society had argued that the Pension Schemes Certification Act (AltZertG) expressly permitted the charging of administrative fees and thus rendered the clauses immune from scrutiny as to their content. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) clearly rejected this argument. The AltZertG merely regulates the certification requirements for pension products, but says nothing about whether certain clauses in general terms and conditions are valid in substance.
The court considered another point to be decisive: according to the statutory framework for a loan agreement under Section 488 of the German Civil Code (BGB), the bank receives its remuneration in the form of the agreed interest. The administration of the contract is in the bank’s own interest and does not serve the customer. If a building society nevertheless passes these costs on to the consumer via its general terms and conditions, it deviates from this fundamental legal principle and places the customer at an unreasonable disadvantage. The clauses are therefore invalid.
What does this mean for Riester building society savers?
There are currently still around 1.5 million active Riester building-society savings contracts in Germany. Many of these contracts contain similar fee clauses. Following the ruling, those affected can reclaim any excess management fees paid, provided that the limitation period has not expired.
In practical terms, this means that fees paid from the start of 2023 onwards are unlikely to have become time-barred. According to the Federal Court of Justice (BGH), with an annual fee of 24 euros, the amount to be reclaimed – including interest – amounts to around 100 euros per year.
- Principle: Administrative fees in Riester building society savings contracts are invalid
- Refunds may be available for payments made from the start of 2023
- This applies to contracts containing the relevant standard terms and conditions
- Issues relating to the limitation period must be examined on a case-by-case basis
Note for clients
Whether a claim for repayment is successful in a specific case, and to what extent, depends on the exact terms of the contract and the payment periods. Anyone wishing to check whether they are entitled to any claims should review the contract documents and seek legal advice.
Federal Court of Justice (BGH), judgement of 28 July 2026, case number XI ZR 83/25
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.