Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Federal Labour Court: Errors in the notice of collective redundancies do not automatically render the redundancies invalid

The Fede­ral Labour Court ruled that minor errors in the noti­ce of coll­ec­ti­ve red­un­dan­cy do not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly ren­der the red­un­dan­ci­es invalid. 
Federal Labour Court: Errors in the notice of collective redundancies do not automatically render the redundancies invalid

Federal Labour Court: Errors in the notice of collective redundancies do not automatically render the redundancies invalid

Any employee who is made red­un­dant and is hoping that the­re are pro­ce­du­ral errors in the legal­ly requi­red noti­ce of coll­ec­ti­ve red­un­dan­cy may, under cer­tain cir­cum­s­tances, no lon­ger be able to auto­ma­ti­cal­ly rely on their employ­ment con­tract remai­ning in force. On 25 June 2026, the Fede­ral Labour Court cla­ri­fied that minor errors in a noti­ce of coll­ec­ti­ve red­un­dan­cy do not neces­s­a­ri­ly affect the vali­di­ty of the red­un­dan­ci­es (Case No. 6 AZR 7/26).

What is a notice of collective redundancy?

If a com­pa­ny intends to make a signi­fi­cant num­ber of employees red­un­dant within 30 days, spe­cial pro­tec­tion under Sec­tion 17 of the Pro­tec­tion Against Dis­mis­sal Act appli­es. The employ­er must first con­sult the works coun­cil, i.e. dis­cuss alter­na­ti­ves with it and explo­re ways of avo­i­ding or miti­ga­ting red­un­dan­ci­es. A full noti­fi­ca­ti­on must then be sub­mit­ted to the rele­vant Job­cent­re. Red­un­dan­ci­es may only be given once a 30-day wai­ting peri­od has elap­sed. In the past, errors in this pro­ce­du­re regu­lar­ly led to red­un­dan­ci­es being dee­med invalid.

The case: Conflicting figures in insolvency proceedings

In the case in ques­ti­on, a key manu­fac­tu­rer had filed for insol­ven­cy in Novem­ber 2024. The insol­ven­cy admi­nis­tra­tor infor­med the works coun­cil of the plan­ned com­ple­te clo­sure of the busi­ness and the red­un­dan­cy of all remai­ning employees. Howe­ver, the con­sul­ta­ti­on let­ter con­tai­ned con­tra­dic­to­ry infor­ma­ti­on: it sta­ted that 61 peo­p­le were to be made red­un­dant, even though only 43 employees were working for the com­pa­ny at that time. An atta­ched table even lis­ted only 31 people.

Fol­lo­wing the con­clu­si­on of a sett­le­ment of inte­rests in Febru­ary 2025, the insol­ven­cy admi­nis­tra­tor sub­mit­ted the noti­ce of coll­ec­ti­ve red­un­dan­ci­es to the Employ­ment Agen­cy. He repor­ted 34 plan­ned red­un­dan­ci­es to the agen­cy; howe­ver, accor­ding to the court, only 31 or 32 were actual­ly car­ri­ed out. One of the affec­ted machi­ne set­ters brought a cla­im against his red­un­dan­cy on ope­ra­tio­nal grounds, citing the incor­rect figures.

Federal Labour Court: Errors that have no bearing on the purpose of the proceedings are harmless

The Hagen Labour Court had initi­al­ly upheld the cla­im. The Hamm Regio­nal Labour Court over­tur­ned this jud­ge­ment on appeal. The Fede­ral Labour Court has now upheld the decis­i­on of the Hamm Regio­nal Labour Court.

The Fede­ral Labour Court’s key fin­ding is that errors which do not run coun­ter to the actu­al pur­po­se of the noti­fi­ca­ti­on pro­ce­du­re do not affect the vali­di­ty of the red­un­dan­ci­es. Despi­te the slight­ly infla­ted figu­re in the noti­fi­ca­ti­on, the Employ­ment Agen­cy was still able to ful­fil its remit, name­ly to miti­ga­te the nega­ti­ve con­se­quen­ces of the mass red­un­dan­cy, prepa­re pla­ce­ment oppor­tu­ni­ties and exami­ne labour mar­ket poli­cy mea­su­res. The slight dis­crepan­cy in the num­ber of red­un­dan­ci­es repor­ted did not affect this.

Nor did the con­tra­dic­to­ry infor­ma­ti­on con­tai­ned in the con­sul­ta­ti­on let­ter to the works coun­cil ren­der it inva­lid. The Fede­ral Labour Court empha­sis­ed that the errors were appa­rent to the works coun­cil and that it was able to ascer­tain the cor­rect figu­res from the atta­ched documents.

What does this mean for those affected?

The jud­ge­ment makes it clear that pro­ce­du­ral irre­gu­la­ri­ties in coll­ec­ti­ve red­un­dan­ci­es no lon­ger auto­ma­ti­cal­ly ser­ve as grounds for a suc­cessful cla­im for pro­tec­tion against unfair dis­mis­sal. The decisi­ve fac­tor is whe­ther a pro­ce­du­ral error actual­ly under­mi­nes the pro­tec­ti­ve pur­po­se of the pro­ce­du­re. For employees who have been made red­un­dant as part of a coll­ec­ti­ve red­un­dan­cy and for com­pa­nies requi­red to car­ry out such a pro­ce­du­re, a tho­rough legal assess­ment of the spe­ci­fic cir­cum­s­tances is advi­sa­ble in all cases.

Source: Hau­fe: Law

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this