Any employee who is made redundant and is hoping that there are procedural errors in the legally required notice of collective redundancy may, under certain circumstances, no longer be able to automatically rely on their employment contract remaining in force. On 25 June 2026, the Federal Labour Court clarified that minor errors in a notice of collective redundancy do not necessarily affect the validity of the redundancies (Case No. 6 AZR 7/26).
What is a notice of collective redundancy?
If a company intends to make a significant number of employees redundant within 30 days, special protection under Section 17 of the Protection Against Dismissal Act applies. The employer must first consult the works council, i.e. discuss alternatives with it and explore ways of avoiding or mitigating redundancies. A full notification must then be submitted to the relevant Jobcentre. Redundancies may only be given once a 30-day waiting period has elapsed. In the past, errors in this procedure regularly led to redundancies being deemed invalid.
The case: Conflicting figures in insolvency proceedings
In the case in question, a key manufacturer had filed for insolvency in November 2024. The insolvency administrator informed the works council of the planned complete closure of the business and the redundancy of all remaining employees. However, the consultation letter contained contradictory information: it stated that 61 people were to be made redundant, even though only 43 employees were working for the company at that time. An attached table even listed only 31 people.
Following the conclusion of a settlement of interests in February 2025, the insolvency administrator submitted the notice of collective redundancies to the Employment Agency. He reported 34 planned redundancies to the agency; however, according to the court, only 31 or 32 were actually carried out. One of the affected machine setters brought a claim against his redundancy on operational grounds, citing the incorrect figures.
Federal Labour Court: Errors that have no bearing on the purpose of the proceedings are harmless
The Hagen Labour Court had initially upheld the claim. The Hamm Regional Labour Court overturned this judgement on appeal. The Federal Labour Court has now upheld the decision of the Hamm Regional Labour Court.
The Federal Labour Court’s key finding is that errors which do not run counter to the actual purpose of the notification procedure do not affect the validity of the redundancies. Despite the slightly inflated figure in the notification, the Employment Agency was still able to fulfil its remit, namely to mitigate the negative consequences of the mass redundancy, prepare placement opportunities and examine labour market policy measures. The slight discrepancy in the number of redundancies reported did not affect this.
Nor did the contradictory information contained in the consultation letter to the works council render it invalid. The Federal Labour Court emphasised that the errors were apparent to the works council and that it was able to ascertain the correct figures from the attached documents.
What does this mean for those affected?
The judgement makes it clear that procedural irregularities in collective redundancies no longer automatically serve as grounds for a successful claim for protection against unfair dismissal. The decisive factor is whether a procedural error actually undermines the protective purpose of the procedure. For employees who have been made redundant as part of a collective redundancy and for companies required to carry out such a procedure, a thorough legal assessment of the specific circumstances is advisable in all cases.
Source: Haufe: Law
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.