Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Dismissal on personal grounds: When employers can lawfully dismiss an employee

Dismissal on personal grounds: When employers can lawfully dismiss an employee

Dis­mis­sal is not always due to mis­con­duct on the part of the employee. Some­ti­mes the reason lies else­whe­re enti­re­ly: in the per­son them­sel­ves. This is pre­cis­e­ly what is cover­ed by what is known as dis­mis­sal on per­so­nal grounds. The Nord­horn Labour Court has now cla­ri­fied in a recent case that even the loss of a dri­ving licence for twel­ve months can jus­ti­fy such a dis­mis­sal if the employee in ques­ti­on is sim­ply unable to work wit­hout a dri­ving licence.

What is dismissal on personal grounds?

A dis­mis­sal on per­so­nal grounds occurs when an employee is per­ma­nent­ly, or for an exten­ded peri­od, unable to per­form the work agreed in their con­tract. It is important to note that this is not a mat­ter of mis­con­duct. The employee need not have done any­thing wrong. The sole decisi­ve fac­tor is that, objec­tively spea­king, they are unable to car­ry out the work.

The clas­sic exam­p­le is dis­mis­sal on health grounds. Howe­ver, other situa­tions may also app­ly: the with­dra­wal of a field worker’s dri­ving licence, a cri­mi­nal offence com­mit­ted out­side working hours that ren­ders the employee unsui­ta­ble for the job, or a leng­thy pri­son sentence.

What requirements must be met?

Not every per­so­nal impe­di­ment is suf­fi­ci­ent grounds for a valid ter­mi­na­ti­on. The courts set high stan­dards. The fol­lo­wing cri­te­ria must all be met:

  • Pes­si­mi­stic out­look:The­re must be a serious likeli­hood that the employee will con­ti­nue to be unable to car­ry out their duties, or will only be able to do so to a limi­t­ed ext­ent, in the future.
  • Signi­fi­cant detri­ment to the company’s inte­rests:The employ­er must be sub­ject to a signi­fi­cant bur­den, for exam­p­le due to lost pro­duc­tion or increased orga­ni­sa­tio­nal costs.
  • Last resort:Dis­mis­sal must only be a last resort. Befo­re taking this step, the employ­er must con­sider whe­ther it is pos­si­ble to trans­fer the employee to ano­ther post or whe­ther fur­ther trai­ning might resol­ve the issue.
  • Balan­cing of inte­rests:The court asses­ses, on a case-by-case basis, how signi­fi­cant the impact is on the employee and how gre­at the bur­den on the busi­ness actual­ly is.

Special considerations in the event of illness

Addi­tio­nal rules app­ly to dis­mis­sals on health grounds. If an employee has been unable to work for more than six weeks within a sin­gle year, employ­ers are obli­ged to offer a work­place inte­gra­ti­on pro­gram­me (BEM for short). This invol­ves working with the employee to find ways for them to return to work. If this offer is not made, the case will be dif­fi­cult to pro­ve in court. Fur­ther­mo­re, accor­ding to the Colo­gne Regio­nal Labour Court, peri­ods of absence resul­ting from a one-off acci­dent do not, in prin­ci­ple, count towards a nega­ti­ve pro­gno­sis for the future.

What are the rules regarding notice periods and severance pay?

Dis­mis­sal on per­so­nal grounds is a dis­mis­sal with noti­ce. This means that the sta­tu­to­ry or coll­ec­ti­ve agree­ment noti­ce peri­ods must be obser­ved. The­re is no auto­ma­tic entit­le­ment to sever­ance pay. Only if a coll­ec­ti­ve agree­ment excludes dis­mis­sal with noti­ce may dis­mis­sal wit­hout noti­ce be con­side­red in excep­tio­nal circumstances.

What does this mean for employers and employees?

It is important for employ­ers to note that acting too hasti­ly car­ri­es legal risks. Anyo­ne who has not exhaus­ted all less seve­re mea­su­res risks losing a case under employ­ment pro­tec­tion legis­la­ti­on. Employees should be awa­re that they may lose their job even through no fault of their own if they are per­ma­nent­ly unable to car­ry out the agreed duties. In both cases, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal advice at an ear­ly stage in order to assess the situa­ti­on realistically.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this