Dismissal is not always due to misconduct on the part of the employee. Sometimes the reason lies elsewhere entirely: in the person themselves. This is precisely what is covered by what is known as dismissal on personal grounds. The Nordhorn Labour Court has now clarified in a recent case that even the loss of a driving licence for twelve months can justify such a dismissal if the employee in question is simply unable to work without a driving licence.
What is dismissal on personal grounds?
A dismissal on personal grounds occurs when an employee is permanently, or for an extended period, unable to perform the work agreed in their contract. It is important to note that this is not a matter of misconduct. The employee need not have done anything wrong. The sole decisive factor is that, objectively speaking, they are unable to carry out the work.
The classic example is dismissal on health grounds. However, other situations may also apply: the withdrawal of a field worker’s driving licence, a criminal offence committed outside working hours that renders the employee unsuitable for the job, or a lengthy prison sentence.
What requirements must be met?
Not every personal impediment is sufficient grounds for a valid termination. The courts set high standards. The following criteria must all be met:
- Pessimistic outlook:There must be a serious likelihood that the employee will continue to be unable to carry out their duties, or will only be able to do so to a limited extent, in the future.
- Significant detriment to the company’s interests:The employer must be subject to a significant burden, for example due to lost production or increased organisational costs.
- Last resort:Dismissal must only be a last resort. Before taking this step, the employer must consider whether it is possible to transfer the employee to another post or whether further training might resolve the issue.
- Balancing of interests:The court assesses, on a case-by-case basis, how significant the impact is on the employee and how great the burden on the business actually is.
Special considerations in the event of illness
Additional rules apply to dismissals on health grounds. If an employee has been unable to work for more than six weeks within a single year, employers are obliged to offer a workplace integration programme (BEM for short). This involves working with the employee to find ways for them to return to work. If this offer is not made, the case will be difficult to prove in court. Furthermore, according to the Cologne Regional Labour Court, periods of absence resulting from a one-off accident do not, in principle, count towards a negative prognosis for the future.
What are the rules regarding notice periods and severance pay?
Dismissal on personal grounds is a dismissal with notice. This means that the statutory or collective agreement notice periods must be observed. There is no automatic entitlement to severance pay. Only if a collective agreement excludes dismissal with notice may dismissal without notice be considered in exceptional circumstances.
What does this mean for employers and employees?
It is important for employers to note that acting too hastily carries legal risks. Anyone who has not exhausted all less severe measures risks losing a case under employment protection legislation. Employees should be aware that they may lose their job even through no fault of their own if they are permanently unable to carry out the agreed duties. In both cases, it is advisable to seek legal advice at an early stage in order to assess the situation realistically.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.