Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Customs duties as extraordinary expenses in the valuation of shares

Customs duties as extraordinary expenses in the valuation of shares

Anyo­ne who gifts shares in a limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) must have their value asses­sed for gift tax pur­po­ses. The so-cal­led sim­pli­fied inco­me-based valua­ti­on method is fre­quent­ly used for this pur­po­se. In a recent jud­ge­ment, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has now cla­ri­fied which expen­ses are con­side­red extra­or­di­na­ry under this valua­ti­on method and may the­r­e­fo­re increase the value of the shares.

What is the simplified income-based valuation method?

If shares in a com­pa­ny are gifted and the­re is no cur­rent mar­ket pri­ce available, the tax office deter­mi­nes the value on the basis of the company’s future ear­ning capa­ci­ty. This is based on the avera­ge annu­al pro­fit of pre­vious years. To ensu­re that this value reflects the future ear­nings situa­ti­on as rea­li­sti­cal­ly as pos­si­ble, the Valua­ti­on Act pro­vi­des for cer­tain adjus­t­ments: one-off or unu­su­al expen­se items are added back to the pro­fit, as they are not expec­ted to affect future results.

The specific case: A freight forwarding company (GmbH) and high customs duties

In the case in ques­ti­on, a share­hol­der in a freight for­war­ding limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) had gifted half of his shares to ano­ther par­ty in 2017. The tax office deter­mi­ned the value of the shares using the sim­pli­fied inco­me approach, adding inte­rest on cus­toms duties as extra­or­di­na­ry expen­ses. This inte­rest had ari­sen becau­se the GmbH had been held lia­ble for cus­toms debts that were lar­ge­ly cau­sed by frau­du­lent acts on the part of third par­ties. The pro­cee­dings had drag­ged on for years, caus­ing the inte­rest bur­den to rise significantly.

The GmbH con­tes­ted this, arguing that the­se inte­rest expen­ses should be deduc­ted in full from its inco­me. The Finan­ce Court dis­missed the cla­im, and the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) upheld this decis­i­on in its jud­ge­ment of 6 May 2026 (case num­ber II R 2/24, published on 16 July 2026).

The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) cla­ri­fied that extra­or­di­na­ry expen­ses within the mea­ning of the Valua­ti­on Act are tho­se which are not expec­ted to affect the annu­al inco­me that can be sus­tain­ab­ly gene­ra­ted in the future. It is irrele­vant whe­ther or not the cos­ts were incur­red in the cour­se of nor­mal busi­ness operations.

Whe­ther expen­ses are to be clas­si­fied as extra­or­di­na­ry must always be asses­sed on the basis of an over­all assess­ment of the indi­vi­du­al case. Three cri­te­ria are decisi­ve in this regard:

  • Legal basis for its crea­ti­on:How did the­se expen­ses ari­se, and is this a one-off or a recur­ring cost?
  • Fre­quen­cy:Have simi­lar expen­ses been incur­red on a regu­lar basis in the past?
  • Reasonable amount:How do the­se expen­ses compa­re with simi­lar, stan­dard costs?

In this spe­ci­fic case, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) reco­g­nis­ed the extra­or­di­na­ry natu­re of the cus­toms inte­rest. The limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) had not demons­tra­ted that com­pa­ra­ble cos­ts were to be expec­ted in the future. The fact that the cos­ts aro­se from frau­du­lent acts com­mit­ted by third par­ties, com­bi­ned with the unu­sual­ly long dura­ti­on of the pro­cee­dings, meant that the expen­ses con­sti­tu­ted a one-off excep­tio­nal case which was not repre­sen­ta­ti­ve of the freight for­war­ding company’s nor­mal pro­fit situation.

What does this mean for business owners and heirs?

The ruling has prac­ti­cal impli­ca­ti­ons for anyo­ne who gifts or bequeaths shares in a com­pa­ny. One-off, extra­or­di­na­ry cos­ts may increase the company’s value as deter­mi­ned for tax pur­po­ses, which in turn affects gift or inhe­ri­tance tax. At the same time, howe­ver, the ruling also opens up the pos­si­bi­li­ty of appro­pria­te­ly exclu­ding unu­su­al expen­ses from the pro­fit base, pro­vi­ded that the­se do not in fact place a per­ma­nent bur­den on the company’s future earnings.

Anyo­ne plan­ning busi­ness suc­ces­si­on or nee­ding to have the value of shares asses­sed for tax pur­po­ses should careful­ly review and docu­ment the break­down of results from pre­vious years. Expert tax advice is high­ly recom­men­ded in all such cases.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this