A window box on the balcony sounds like a harmless pastime. In practice, however, it has been the subject of several court cases. Whether a window box may be hung on the outside or inside, who is liable for any damage, and what rights a flat owners’ association has are, from a legal perspective, anything but clear-cut.
WEG resolution: Interior decorations to be displayed in accordance with the owners’ resolution
The Munich Local Court has ruled that a owners’ meeting may pass a resolution requiring all balcony planters to be hung on the inside in future. In this specific case, heavy ceramic planters had been hung on the outside without being adequately secured against falling. Furthermore, overflowing planters had already discoloured the façade. The court regarded the resolution as a permissible measure of preventative maintenance. Whether anything had actually happened to date was irrelevant. The façade and the external areas of the balconies form part of the common property, meaning that the owners’ association alone can decide on their design. However, the resolution was restricted in one respect: an automatic obligation to bear the costs in the event of breaches of the rules without proof of fault is void, as it deviates from the legal principle of fault-based liability. (Munich Local Court, judgement of 12 November 2024, ref. 1293 C 12154/24 WEG)
Watering plants whilst the terrace below is occupied: a claim for an injunction may be possible
The Munich I Regional Court has clarified that a flat owner must not water their balcony plants if there are people on the terrace directly below. The water running off the balcony constitutes an unreasonable nuisance under the Condominium Act. Affected owners may, in such cases, assert a claim for an injunction. (Munich Regional Court I, judgement of 15 September 2014, Case No. 1 S 1836/13 WEG)
Tenancy law: External storage boxes are not always permitted
In principle, placing and hanging plants is considered normal use of the tenanted property. However, a landlord may prohibit the attachment of planters to the outside of the balcony parapet if there are reasonable grounds for doing so. The Berlin Regional Court has recognised such a ground where there is a car park beneath the balcony: Planters falling from the balcony pose a danger to vehicles and people in that area. As the property owner, the landlord is obliged to prevent such dangers. (Berlin Regional Court, judgement of 3 July 2012, ref. 65 S 40/12)
On the other hand, the Hamburg Regional Court has ruled that external planters cannot be banned across the board. Provided that no specific danger has been proven and the planters are securely fixed to withstand the wind, their use constitutes a lawful exercise of the tenant’s rights under the tenancy agreement. The burden of proof regarding a specific danger lies with the landlord. (Hamburg Regional Court, judgement of 7 December 2004, ref. 316 S 79/04)
Overhanging vegetation beyond the parapet: consideration is required
If the plants grow well beyond the balcony parapet and, as a result, cause a nuisance to the neighbour’s terrace by falling plant debris or bird droppings, the landlord must take action. The Berlin Regional Court has ordered a landlord to require his tenant to trim the plants back. Anyone who plants their balcony in such a way that neighbours are permanently inconvenienced is using the let property in breach of the tenancy agreement. (Berlin Regional Court, judgement of 28 October 2002, ref. 67 S 127/02)
The owners’ association cannot take legal action against tenants directly
A flat owners’ association cannot itself prohibit a tenant from installing balcony planters. This has been clarified by the Munich I Regional Court. The right to require the tenant to remove them lies solely with the landlord and is based on the tenancy agreement. The owners’ association has no contractual claim of its own against the tenant. (Munich Regional Court I, judgement of 8 May 2001, ref. 13 S 2348/01)
What this means for tenants and homeowners
The legal situation regarding window boxes varies from case to case. The key factors are how the planters are actually secured, the location of the balcony, the tenancy agreement and any resolutions passed by the owners’ association. Anyone who is unsure whether their planting is permitted, or who, as a property owner, wishes to enforce regulations, should seek legal advice if in doubt.
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.