Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Pension commitments from the age of 60: When is there a risk of a hidden distribution of profits?

A pen­si­on com­mit­ment made after the age of 60 may con­sti­tu­te a hid­den dis­tri­bu­ti­on of pro­fits. The Müns­ter Finan­ce Court rules on the limits on pen­si­on accru­al for share­hol­ders in limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­nies (GmbHs).
Pension commitments from the age of 60: When is there a risk of a hidden distribution of profits?

Pension commitments from the age of 60: When is there a risk of a hidden distribution of profits?

A limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) that grants a pen­si­on com­mit­ment to its mana­ging direc­tor or a working share­hol­der only after they have rea­ched the age of 60 runs the risk that the tax aut­ho­ri­ties will tre­at the pro­vi­si­ons set asi­de in full as a hid­den dis­tri­bu­ti­on of pro­fits (vGA). This was deci­ded by the Müns­ter Finan­ce Court in its jud­ge­ment of 1 July 2026 (Ref. 10 K 2553/24 K,G,F).

The facts: Pension commitments at the ages of 62 and 63

In Janu­ary 2020, a limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) issued iden­ti­cal pen­si­on com­mit­ments to both share­hol­ders, each of whom held 50 per cent of the shares. The sche­me pro­vi­ded for month­ly con­tri­bu­ti­ons of 2,500 euros each, bea­ring inte­rest at 4.5 per cent per annum. The accu­mu­la­ted capi­tal was to be paid out upon rea­ching the age of 70. The pro­blem was that the mana­ging direc­tor was alre­a­dy 62 years old at the time the com­mit­ment was made, whilst his wife and co-share­hol­der was 63. At the end of 2020, the GmbH reco­g­nis­ed pen­si­on pro­vi­si­ons total­ling around 281,676 euros.

During a tax audit, the tax office clas­si­fied the­se pro­vi­si­ons in their enti­re­ty as hid­den dis­tri­bu­ti­ons of pro­fits. Put sim­ply, a hid­den divi­dend ari­ses when a limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) grants a share­hol­der a finan­cial advan­ta­ge that it would not have gran­ted to an unre­la­ted third par­ty. It increa­ses the company’s taxa­ble pro­fit and may result in the share­hol­der being lia­ble for inco­me tax.

The court’s reasoning

The Müns­ter Fis­cal Court upheld the tax office’s view. Two points were decisi­ve in this regard.

  • Con­trol­ling posi­ti­on held by both share­hol­ders:Alt­hough each held only 50 per cent of the shares, the court regard­ed both as having a con­trol­ling inte­rest on the grounds that their inte­rests were ali­gned. This was indi­ca­ted by the fact that they had recei­ved iden­ti­cal pen­si­on com­mit­ments at the same time.
  • Excee­ding the maxi­mum age for admis­si­on:For con­trol­ling share­hol­ders, an age limit of 60 years appli­es for tax pur­po­ses. Anyo­ne who is older at the time the pen­si­on com­mit­ment is gran­ted does not meet the so-cal­led ‘ves­t­ing test’. This test asses­ses whe­ther the employee can still earn the right to the pro­mi­sed pen­si­on during the remai­ning peri­od of employment.

Fur­ther­mo­re, the­re were fewer than 10 years bet­ween the date of the com­mit­ment and the plan­ned reti­re­ment age of 70. Howe­ver, case law requi­res con­trol­ling share­hol­ders to have at least this period.

The court rejec­ted the plain­ti­ffs’ objec­tion that the ves­t­ing peri­od under the Occu­pa­tio­nal Pen­si­ons Act (BetrAVG) had sin­ce been redu­ced to just three years and must the­r­e­fo­re also app­ly for tax pur­po­ses. The court held that the Occu­pa­tio­nal Pen­si­ons Act pur­sues dif­fe­rent objec­ti­ves to tax law.

Appeal allowed: fundamental issues remain unresolved

The Müns­ter Fis­cal Court has express­ly aut­ho­ri­sed an appeal to the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court becau­se the jud­ge­ment rai­ses ques­ti­ons of prin­ci­ple. Spe­ci­fi­cal­ly, the issues at sta­ke are whe­ther the ves­t­ing rules also app­ly to com­mit­ments that are ful­ly pre-fun­ded, whe­ther the maxi­mum com­mit­ment age of 60 is still appro­pria­te, and whe­ther the 10-year peri­od is still jus­ti­fied fol­lo­wing the reduc­tion of the BetrAVG time limits. The final cla­ri­fi­ca­ti­on of the­se issues is the­r­e­fo­re reser­ved for the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court.

What does this mean for shareholders in a GmbH?

Any share­hol­der-mana­ging direc­tor or working share­hol­der of a GmbH who is plan­ning to recei­ve, or has alre­a­dy recei­ved, a pen­si­on com­mit­ment should have the tax requi­re­ments careful­ly review­ed. The limits at issue here – a maxi­mum com­mit­ment age of 60 and at least 10 years remai­ning until reti­re­ment – are bin­ding accor­ding to the cur­rent sta­te of case law. It remains to be seen whe­ther the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) will relax the­se requi­re­ments on appeal. In any case, it is advi­sa­ble to seek expert tax advice befo­re a pen­si­on com­mit­ment is granted.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this