Anyone who looks after foster children in a so-called family-style residential group and receives public funding for this often hopes to qualify for the tax exemption under Section 3(11) of the Income Tax Act. However, in a recent judgement, the Münster Finance Court has clarified that this tax exemption does not apply automatically. The decisive factor is whether the care provided is in fact comparable to full-time family care or whether it is more akin to a professional business operation.
What was the background to this?
A woman ran a family-style residential group in her own home and took in four foster children there. From 1 May of the year in question, she held an operating licence under Section 45 of Book VIII of the Social Code (SGB VIII), which had been granted to her by the State Youth Welfare Office. The licence stipulated a staffing level of 2.66 full-time equivalents and expressly restricted the range of services to so-called ‘intensive care’ services.
The claimant took the view that her income was tax-free. She pointed out that, with four children, she was well below the threshold of six children recognised by case law and the tax authorities, and that their living arrangements were typical of a family. The tax office took a different view and taxed the income in full.
What was the court’s ruling?
The Münster Finance Court dismissed the claim. It found that, in this case, the care provided was not predominantly comparable to full-time care within the meaning of Section 33 of Book VIII of the Social Code (SGB VIII). The crux of the reasoning was that the claimant was legally obliged to employ at least two further qualified staff members. Given the prescribed staff-to-resident ratio, their role could not be regarded as subordinate or merely supportive, but constituted a substantial part of the care service provided.
The court also emphasised that the organisational framework clearly ruled out a purely family-based arrangement. The claimant selected staff on her own initiative, concluded employment contracts and was responsible for paying wages. Despite wage costs of around 78,000 euros, she made a six-figure profit. This is simply not comparable to a family care situation where care is provided free of charge.
Nor did the so-called presumption rule – under which, as a general rule, it is assumed that no gainful employment takes place when up to six children are in care – help the claimant. The Federal Fiscal Court has previously ruled that this presumption does not apply in the case of intensive care programmes. By contrast, the fact that there were no separate living areas was deemed to be of secondary importance.
What does this mean for those affected?
The ruling shows that tax exemption for income from care allowances cannot be taken for granted. Anyone running a residential care home with professional structures – that is, with employed staff, substantial income and an official licence to provide intensive care – must expect the tax office to classify the activity as gainful employment.
Ultimately, the decisive factor is always whether the specific care arrangement is similar to full-time family care or more akin to a professional care service. The distinction is blurred, but the tax implications are significant.
The appeal proceedings are pending before the Federal Fiscal Court under case number VIII R 17/26, meaning that a ruling by the highest court is still pending.
Judgment of the Münster Finance Court of 4 November 2025, case number 14 K 2262/22 E.Anyone who finds themselves in a similar situation should seek tax advice before declaring any income as tax-free on their tax return.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.