Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Foster children in family-style residential schemes: income is not tax-free

Anyo­ne who looks after fos­ter child­ren in a resi­den­ti­al group under the super­vi­si­on of qua­li­fied staff can­not cla­im tax exemp­ti­on. The Müns­ter Finan­ce Court has ruled unequivocally. 
Foster children in family-style residential schemes: income is not tax-free

Foster children in family-style residential schemes: income is not tax-free

Anyo­ne who looks after fos­ter child­ren in a so-cal­led fami­ly-style resi­den­ti­al group and recei­ves public fun­ding for this often hopes to qua­li­fy for the tax exemp­ti­on under Sec­tion 3(11) of the Inco­me Tax Act. Howe­ver, in a recent jud­ge­ment, the Müns­ter Finan­ce Court has cla­ri­fied that this tax exemp­ti­on does not app­ly auto­ma­ti­cal­ly. The decisi­ve fac­tor is whe­ther the care pro­vi­ded is in fact com­pa­ra­ble to full-time fami­ly care or whe­ther it is more akin to a pro­fes­sio­nal busi­ness operation.

What was the background to this?

A woman ran a fami­ly-style resi­den­ti­al group in her own home and took in four fos­ter child­ren the­re. From 1 May of the year in ques­ti­on, she held an ope­ra­ting licence under Sec­tion 45 of Book VIII of the Social Code (SGB VIII), which had been gran­ted to her by the Sta­te Youth Wel­fa­re Office. The licence sti­pu­la­ted a staf­fing level of 2.66 full-time equi­va­lents and express­ly rest­ric­ted the ran­ge of ser­vices to so-cal­led ‘inten­si­ve care’ services.

The clai­mant took the view that her inco­me was tax-free. She poin­ted out that, with four child­ren, she was well below the thres­hold of six child­ren reco­g­nis­ed by case law and the tax aut­ho­ri­ties, and that their living arran­ge­ments were typi­cal of a fami­ly. The tax office took a dif­fe­rent view and taxed the inco­me in full.

What was the court’s ruling?

The Müns­ter Finan­ce Court dis­missed the cla­im. It found that, in this case, the care pro­vi­ded was not pre­do­mi­nant­ly com­pa­ra­ble to full-time care within the mea­ning of Sec­tion 33 of Book VIII of the Social Code (SGB VIII). The crux of the reaso­ning was that the clai­mant was legal­ly obli­ged to employ at least two fur­ther qua­li­fied staff mem­bers. Given the pre­scri­bed staff-to-resi­dent ratio, their role could not be regard­ed as sub­or­di­na­te or mere­ly sup­port­i­ve, but con­sti­tu­ted a sub­stan­ti­al part of the care ser­vice provided.

The court also empha­sis­ed that the orga­ni­sa­tio­nal frame­work cle­ar­ly ruled out a purely fami­ly-based arran­ge­ment. The clai­mant sel­ec­ted staff on her own initia­ti­ve, con­cluded employ­ment con­tracts and was respon­si­ble for pay­ing wages. Despi­te wage cos­ts of around 78,000 euros, she made a six-figu­re pro­fit. This is sim­ply not com­pa­ra­ble to a fami­ly care situa­ti­on whe­re care is pro­vi­ded free of charge.

Nor did the so-cal­led pre­sump­ti­on rule – under which, as a gene­ral rule, it is assu­med that no gain­ful employ­ment takes place when up to six child­ren are in care – help the clai­mant. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has pre­vious­ly ruled that this pre­sump­ti­on does not app­ly in the case of inten­si­ve care pro­gram­mes. By con­trast, the fact that the­re were no sepa­ra­te living are­as was dee­med to be of secon­da­ry importance.

What does this mean for those affected?

The ruling shows that tax exemp­ti­on for inco­me from care allo­wan­ces can­not be taken for gran­ted. Anyo­ne run­ning a resi­den­ti­al care home with pro­fes­sio­nal struc­tures – that is, with employ­ed staff, sub­stan­ti­al inco­me and an offi­ci­al licence to pro­vi­de inten­si­ve care – must expect the tax office to clas­si­fy the acti­vi­ty as gain­ful employment.

Ulti­m­ate­ly, the decisi­ve fac­tor is always whe­ther the spe­ci­fic care arran­ge­ment is simi­lar to full-time fami­ly care or more akin to a pro­fes­sio­nal care ser­vice. The distinc­tion is blur­red, but the tax impli­ca­ti­ons are significant.

The appeal pro­cee­dings are pen­ding befo­re the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court under case num­ber VIII R 17/26, mea­ning that a ruling by the hig­hest court is still pending.

Judgment of the Müns­ter Finan­ce Court of 4 Novem­ber 2025, case num­ber 14 K 2262/22 E.Anyo­ne who finds them­sel­ves in a simi­lar situa­ti­on should seek tax advice befo­re decla­ring any inco­me as tax-free on their tax return.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this