Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Federal Court of Justice: Annual fees for Riester building society savings schemes are unlawful

Federal Court of Justice: Annual fees for Riester building society savings schemes are unlawful

Anyo­ne with a Ries­ter buil­ding socie­ty savings sche­me has often been pay­ing an annu­al fee to their buil­ding socie­ty for years. The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce has now ruled that such fees are unlawful. In many cases, affec­ted con­su­mers can cla­im back any excess amounts paid.

What was it about?

The Fede­ra­ti­on of Ger­man Con­su­mer Orga­ni­sa­ti­ons (vzbv) brought a legal action against the gene­ral terms and con­di­ti­ons of a buil­ding socie­ty. The buil­ding socie­ty had included a clau­se in its con­tracts pro­vi­ding for an annu­al admi­nis­tra­ti­on fee. Until ear­ly 2022, this was 15 euros per year; the­re­af­ter, it was 24 euros for new con­tracts. The clau­se also allo­wed the buil­ding socie­ty to adjust the fee in the event of rising admi­nis­tra­ti­ve costs.

The Regio­nal Court had initi­al­ly dis­missed the cla­im, and the Court of Appeal upheld that decis­i­on. Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) ruled enti­re­ly in favour of the vzbv on appeal.

Why are the clauses invalid?

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) clas­si­fied the remu­ne­ra­ti­on clau­ses as so-cal­led ancil­la­ry pri­ce agree­ments. The­se are pro­vi­si­ons which do not deter­mi­ne the main pri­ce of a con­tract, but rather govern ancil­la­ry cos­ts or addi­tio­nal remu­ne­ra­ti­on. Such clau­ses are sub­ject to the scru­ti­ny of stan­dard terms and con­di­ti­ons under Sec­tion 307 of the Ger­man Civil Code.

The buil­ding socie­ty had argued that the Pen­si­on Sche­mes Cer­ti­fi­ca­ti­on Act (Alt­ZertG) express­ly per­mit­ted the char­ging of admi­nis­tra­ti­ve fees and thus ren­de­red the clau­ses immu­ne from scru­ti­ny as to their con­tent. The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) cle­ar­ly rejec­ted this argu­ment. The Alt­ZertG mere­ly regu­la­tes the cer­ti­fi­ca­ti­on requi­re­ments for pen­si­on pro­ducts, but says not­hing about whe­ther cer­tain clau­ses in gene­ral terms and con­di­ti­ons are valid in substance.

The court con­side­red ano­ther point to be decisi­ve: accor­ding to the sta­tu­to­ry frame­work for a loan agree­ment under Sec­tion 488 of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB), the bank recei­ves its remu­ne­ra­ti­on in the form of the agreed inte­rest. The admi­nis­tra­ti­on of the con­tract is in the bank’s own inte­rest and does not ser­ve the cus­to­mer. If a buil­ding socie­ty nevert­hel­ess pas­ses the­se cos­ts on to the con­su­mer via its gene­ral terms and con­di­ti­ons, it devia­tes from this fun­da­men­tal legal prin­ci­ple and places the cus­to­mer at an unre­asonable dis­ad­van­ta­ge. The clau­ses are the­r­e­fo­re invalid.

What does this mean for Riester building society savers?

The­re are curr­ent­ly still around 1.5 mil­li­on acti­ve Ries­ter buil­ding-socie­ty savings con­tracts in Ger­ma­ny. Many of the­se con­tracts con­tain simi­lar fee clau­ses. Fol­lo­wing the ruling, tho­se affec­ted can recla­im any excess manage­ment fees paid, pro­vi­ded that the limi­ta­ti­on peri­od has not expired.

In prac­ti­cal terms, this means that fees paid from the start of 2023 onwards are unli­kely to have beco­me time-bar­red. Accor­ding to the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH), with an annu­al fee of 24 euros, the amount to be reclai­med – inclu­ding inte­rest – amounts to around 100 euros per year.

  • Prin­ci­ple: Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve fees in Ries­ter buil­ding socie­ty savings con­tracts are invalid
  • Refunds may be available for pay­ments made from the start of 2023
  • This appli­es to con­tracts con­tai­ning the rele­vant stan­dard terms and conditions
  • Issues rela­ting to the limi­ta­ti­on peri­od must be exami­ned on a case-by-case basis

Note for clients

Whe­ther a cla­im for repay­ment is suc­cessful in a spe­ci­fic case, and to what ext­ent, depends on the exact terms of the con­tract and the pay­ment peri­ods. Anyo­ne wis­hing to check whe­ther they are entit­led to any claims should review the con­tract docu­ments and seek legal advice.

Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH), jud­ge­ment of 28 July 2026, case num­ber XI ZR 83/25

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this