Any entrepreneur or company that holds securities as part of its business assets will, sooner or later, encounter what are known as capital measures. Share splits, bonus shares, subscription rights or spin-offs alter the portfolio without a traditional purchase or sale taking place. That is precisely what makes them so tricky: because no money changes hands, they are often overlooked in the accounts. A mistake that only comes back to haunt you years later.
Why capital measures must not simply be ignored
The tax and accounting implications of a corporate action often only become apparent when the securities are subsequently sold. At that point, the original acquisition costs are required to calculate the profit. If these were incorrectly updated or not adjusted at all in the course of a corporate action, the tax liability will ultimately be incorrect. This is precisely what the tax authorities check during tax audits.
Three basic types, three different treatments
Capital measures can be divided into three groups, each of which has different accounting implications:
- Purely internal transformationssuch as share splits or reverse splits: no tax realisation takes place in such cases. The previous acquisition costs are simply allocated across a different number of shares.
- Inflow processessuch as bonus shares or stock dividends: these may be treated as distributions in kind and give rise to taxable income, on which capital gains tax may, under certain circumstances, be withheld.
- Extraction processessuch as subscription rights or spin-offs: in such cases, the original cost must be allocated between the existing security and the newly created security or right.
Share splits and reverse splits: just a matter of maths
In a traditional share split, existing shares are split, for example at a ratio of 1 to 2. The total cost base remains unchanged, whilst the amount per share falls accordingly. For tax purposes, this results in neither income nor an expense. With a reverse split, the process is the other way round: several shares are consolidated into one, and the acquisition cost is spread across fewer shares.
Bonus shares: Not the same as a share split
Although bonus shares appear similar to a share split, they are treated fundamentally differently. Under commercial law, the additional shares recorded are regarded as a distribution in kind. The value allocated must be recognised as income. In practice, however, valuation is difficult because reliable documentation regarding the value to be recognised is often lacking.
Subscription rights and spin-offs: Allocation of acquisition costs
In the event of a capital increase, existing shareholders are granted subscription rights, which they can use to subscribe for new shares. A portion of the acquisition cost of the existing share is allocated to the subscription right. In practice, in the absence of a reliable basis for valuation, this portion is often set at zero, which means that if the subscription right is sold, the entire proceeds are treated as a capital gain.
In a spin-off, one security is split off to form a second security with its own security identification number. The original acquisition cost must be allocated between the two securities. If this results in fractional amounts, these are often sold and paid out as a cash settlement. This transaction must then be recorded separately as a disposal.
Legal form and documentation are crucial
Whether securities are held by a limited liability company (GmbH), a partnership or a foundation can have a significant impact on their tax treatment. It is not possible to apply a blanket transfer from one legal form to another.
Equally important is keeping a complete record throughout the entire holding period: notices regarding capital measures, custody account statements, exchange ratios and updates to the cost base should be carefully retained. This is the only way to correctly calculate any capital gain on a subsequent sale.
Anyone who holds securities as part of their business assets should seek tax advice at an early stage whenever a capital transaction is planned, in order to avoid mistakes that may only become apparent at the time of sale in the form of additional tax liabilities.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.