Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Accounting for capital measures correctly: What share splits, bonus shares and spin-offs mean for the balance sheet

Accounting for capital measures correctly: What share splits, bonus shares and spin-offs mean for the balance sheet

Any entre­pre­neur or com­pa­ny that holds secu­ri­ties as part of its busi­ness assets will, soo­ner or later, encoun­ter what are known as capi­tal mea­su­res. Share splits, bonus shares, sub­scrip­ti­on rights or spin-offs alter the port­fo­lio wit­hout a tra­di­tio­nal purcha­se or sale taking place. That is pre­cis­e­ly what makes them so tri­cky: becau­se no money chan­ges hands, they are often over­loo­ked in the accounts. A mista­ke that only comes back to haunt you years later.

Why capital measures must not simply be ignored

The tax and accoun­ting impli­ca­ti­ons of a cor­po­ra­te action often only beco­me appa­rent when the secu­ri­ties are sub­se­quent­ly sold. At that point, the ori­gi­nal acqui­si­ti­on cos­ts are requi­red to cal­cu­la­te the pro­fit. If the­se were incor­rect­ly updated or not adjus­ted at all in the cour­se of a cor­po­ra­te action, the tax lia­bi­li­ty will ulti­m­ate­ly be incor­rect. This is pre­cis­e­ly what the tax aut­ho­ri­ties check during tax audits.

Three basic types, three different treatments

Capi­tal mea­su­res can be divi­ded into three groups, each of which has dif­fe­rent accoun­ting implications:

  • Purely inter­nal trans­for­ma­ti­onssuch as share splits or rever­se splits: no tax rea­li­sa­ti­on takes place in such cases. The pre­vious acqui­si­ti­on cos­ts are sim­ply allo­ca­ted across a dif­fe­rent num­ber of shares.
  • Inflow pro­ces­sessuch as bonus shares or stock divi­dends: the­se may be trea­ted as dis­tri­bu­ti­ons in kind and give rise to taxa­ble inco­me, on which capi­tal gains tax may, under cer­tain cir­cum­s­tances, be withheld.
  • Extra­c­tion pro­ces­sessuch as sub­scrip­ti­on rights or spin-offs: in such cases, the ori­gi­nal cost must be allo­ca­ted bet­ween the exis­ting secu­ri­ty and the new­ly crea­ted secu­ri­ty or right.

Share splits and reverse splits: just a matter of maths

In a tra­di­tio­nal share split, exis­ting shares are split, for exam­p­le at a ratio of 1 to 2. The total cost base remains unch­an­ged, whilst the amount per share falls accor­din­gly. For tax pur­po­ses, this results in neither inco­me nor an expen­se. With a rever­se split, the pro­cess is the other way round: seve­ral shares are con­so­li­da­ted into one, and the acqui­si­ti­on cost is spread across fewer shares.

Bonus shares: Not the same as a share split

Alt­hough bonus shares appear simi­lar to a share split, they are trea­ted fun­da­men­tal­ly dif­fer­ent­ly. Under com­mer­cial law, the addi­tio­nal shares recor­ded are regard­ed as a dis­tri­bu­ti­on in kind. The value allo­ca­ted must be reco­g­nis­ed as inco­me. In prac­ti­ce, howe­ver, valua­ti­on is dif­fi­cult becau­se relia­ble docu­men­ta­ti­on regar­ding the value to be reco­g­nis­ed is often lacking.

Subscription rights and spin-offs: Allocation of acquisition costs

In the event of a capi­tal increase, exis­ting share­hol­ders are gran­ted sub­scrip­ti­on rights, which they can use to sub­scri­be for new shares. A por­ti­on of the acqui­si­ti­on cost of the exis­ting share is allo­ca­ted to the sub­scrip­ti­on right. In prac­ti­ce, in the absence of a relia­ble basis for valua­ti­on, this por­ti­on is often set at zero, which means that if the sub­scrip­ti­on right is sold, the enti­re pro­ceeds are trea­ted as a capi­tal gain.

In a spin-off, one secu­ri­ty is split off to form a second secu­ri­ty with its own secu­ri­ty iden­ti­fi­ca­ti­on num­ber. The ori­gi­nal acqui­si­ti­on cost must be allo­ca­ted bet­ween the two secu­ri­ties. If this results in frac­tion­al amounts, the­se are often sold and paid out as a cash sett­le­ment. This tran­sac­tion must then be recor­ded sepa­ra­te­ly as a disposal.

Legal form and documentation are crucial

Whe­ther secu­ri­ties are held by a limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH), a part­ner­ship or a foun­da­ti­on can have a signi­fi­cant impact on their tax tre­at­ment. It is not pos­si­ble to app­ly a blan­ket trans­fer from one legal form to another.

Equal­ly important is kee­ping a com­ple­te record throug­hout the enti­re hol­ding peri­od: noti­ces regar­ding capi­tal mea­su­res, cus­t­ody account state­ments, exch­an­ge rati­os and updates to the cost base should be careful­ly retai­ned. This is the only way to cor­rect­ly cal­cu­la­te any capi­tal gain on a sub­se­quent sale.

Anyo­ne who holds secu­ri­ties as part of their busi­ness assets should seek tax advice at an ear­ly stage when­ever a capi­tal tran­sac­tion is plan­ned, in order to avo­id mista­kes that may only beco­me appa­rent at the time of sale in the form of addi­tio­nal tax liabilities.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this