In August 2026, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) accepted a number of new cases for adjudication, which may have significant practical implications for business owners, employees and private individuals. We outline the most important cases and explain why they are relevant.
Directors’ liability following departure
One particularly relevant case concerns the tax liability of former managing directors (Ref. VII R 16/26). The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) is to clarify whether a former managing director can still be required to submit tax returns or tax declarations after leaving a company limited by shares. Specifically, the issue is whether liability is limited to obligations that already existed at the time of leaving the company. For individuals who are stepping down from, or have already stepped down from, a managing director role, this decision could have far-reaching consequences.
Hidden profit distributions in family employment relationships
Two cases deal with hidden profit distributions, that is, benefits which a limited liability company (GmbH) grants to its shareholder or related parties without adequate consideration. Case I R 9/26 concerns expenses arising from an employment relationship between the GmbH and the daughter of the shareholder-managing director, as well as the private use of a company car by that daughter. Case VIII R 23/25 addresses the question of how contributions to a working time account held by a controlling shareholder-managing director should be treated for tax purposes, and when exactly a payment is deemed to have been received.
Gift tax and property values
There are two procedures of particular significance for property owners and individuals who transfer or receive property as part of a gift. Case II R 11/26 clarifies whether, in the case of a co-ownership share, it can be demonstrated that this share is worth less than the calculated proportion of the total value of the property, and whether, in the case of properties encumbered by a usufruct, an additional discount should be recognised due to reduced marketability. A usufruct is a right in rem to use the property, which can significantly reduce the market value of a property. Case II R 20/26 concerns whether a building plot is to be classified as tax-privileged business assets under the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act.
Property tax: constitutional issues and flat ownership
Two cases concerning property tax are also pending. Case II R 21/26 concerns the constitutionality of the Lower Saxony Property Tax Act. As several federal states have introduced their own property tax models, rulings on this matter could set a precedent nationwide. Case II R 14/26 is determining whether, in the case of a single block of flats comprising several flats under civil law, a single property tax value should be determined or whether a separate value should be established for each individual flat.
Equalisation of accrued gains and private sales transactions
Case IX R 10/26 is of particular interest to those involved in divorce proceedings. It concerns the question of whether the transfer of property as part of a divorce settlement can be regarded as a taxable private sale if, at the same time, claims for maintenance and equalisation of accrued gains are waived.
What does this mean for you?
Pending Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) proceedings do not yet constitute final judgements, but they do highlight which tax issues remain unresolved in principle at present. In ongoing proceedings involving comparable facts, it may be possible to apply for the proceedings to be stayed until the BFH has reached a decision. Anyone affected by any of the issues mentioned should discuss this with a tax or legal adviser.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.