— title: “Shop­ping bas­ket remin­ders by email: Data pro­tec­tion aut­ho­ri­ty clas­si­fies them as unaut­ho­ri­sed adver­ti­sing” descrip­ti­on: “North Rhi­ne-West­pha­lia Data Pro­tec­tion Aut­ho­ri­ty: Aban­do­ned bas­ket emails con­sti­tu­te direct mar­ke­ting and are unaut­ho­ri­sed wit­hout con­sent. What online retail­ers need to know now.” url: https://kanzlei-reese.de/en/shopping-basket-reminders-by-email-data-protection-authority-classifies/ type: “post” lan­guage: “en-GB” site: “Recht &amp; Steu­ern Ina Ree­se Flens­burg Law Firm” published: 17 Octo­ber 2026 15:40:04 +02:00 modi­fied: 2026–10-17T15:40:04+02:00 aut­hor: “Recht &amp; Steu­ern Ree­se Flens­burg” cate­go­ries: “Trade­mark &amp; Inter­net Law” tags: “Data Pro­tec­tion, GDPR, Email Mar­ke­ting, E‑commerce, Unfair Com­pe­ti­ti­on Act, Shop­ping Bas­ket Remin­ders” image: https://kanzlei-reese.de/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/knp-teaser-131.jpg — # Shop­ping bas­ket remin­ders by email: Data pro­tec­tion aut­ho­ri­ty clas­si­fies them as unaut­ho­ri­sed adver­ti­sing Many online shops auto­ma­ti­cal­ly send emails when a cus­to­mer has added pro­ducts to their shop­ping bas­ket but has not com­ple­ted the purcha­se. What retail­ers often descri­be as a useful ser­vice is, in the view of the Sta­te Com­mis­sio­ner for Data Pro­tec­tion and Free­dom of Infor­ma­ti­on in North Rhi­ne-West­pha­lia (LDI NRW), in most cases unaut­ho­ri­sed adver­ti­sing. ## How the assess­ment came about The case aro­se from a com­plaint by a cus­to­mer who, after aban­do­ning an order, recei­ved no fewer than three such remin­der emails from an online retail­er. The retail­er did not regard this as adver­ti­sing, but rather as a form of ser­vice com­mu­ni­ca­ti­on in the customer’s best inte­rests. The data pro­tec­tion aut­ho­ri­ty took a fun­da­men­tal­ly dif­fe­rent view and set out the detail­ed reaso­ning behind its assess­ment in its 31st Annu­al Report for the year 2025. ## No lon­ger a pre-con­trac­tu­al rela­ti­onship Anyo­ne who lea­ves an online shop wit­hout making a purcha­se is ther­eby cle­ar­ly indi­ca­ting that they do not wish to enter into a con­tract. Alt­hough the Gene­ral Data Pro­tec­tion Regu­la­ti­on (GDPR) per­mits data pro­ces­sing in the con­text of pre-con­trac­tu­al mea­su­res under cer­tain con­di­ti­ons, this basis cea­ses to app­ly as soon as the cus­to­mer lea­ves the shop wit­hout pla­cing an order. The pre-con­trac­tu­al rela­ti­onship is thus ter­mi­na­ted. ## Remin­der emails are adver­ti­sing, not a ser­vice The LDI NRW cle­ar­ly clas­si­fies aban­do­ned bas­ket emails as direct mar­ke­ting. Accor­ding to the defi­ni­ti­on in an EU direc­ti­ve, this appli­es to any com­mu­ni­ca­ti­on made with the aim of pro­mo­ting the sale of goods or ser­vices. Remin­der emails are aimed pre­cis­e­ly at this: They build on obser­ved purcha­sing beha­viour and are inten­ded to per­sua­de the cus­to­mer to make a purcha­se after all. This is clas­sic retar­ge­ting. Under the Unfair Com­pe­ti­ti­on Act (UWG), email adver­ti­sing is, in prin­ci­ple, only per­mit­ted with the recipient’s express con­sent. Such con­sent can be obtai­ned, for exam­p­le, via a check­box that must be actively ticked and a so-cal­led dou­ble opt-in pro­ce­du­re, simi­lar to sub­scrib­ing to a news­let­ter. ## Excep­ti­on for exis­ting cus­to­mers Howe­ver, the UWG pro­vi­des for an excep­ti­on for exis­ting cus­to­mers. Anyo­ne who has pre­vious­ly made a purcha­se from a retail­er may, under cer­tain con­di­ti­ons, be cont­ac­ted by email wit­hout requi­ring new con­sent. For this to app­ly, four con­di­ti­ons must be met simul­ta­neous­ly: – The email address was coll­ec­ted in con­nec­tion with a pre­vious purcha­se. – Only the retailer’s own, simi­lar pro­ducts are being adver­ti­sed. – The cus­to­mer has not objec­ted to such use. – The cus­to­mer was cle­ar­ly infor­med, both when the address was coll­ec­ted and on each sub­se­quent occa­si­on, that they may object to its use at any time, free of char­ge. If the­se con­di­ti­ons are met, the retail­er may base the remin­der email on what is known as a ‘legi­ti­ma­te inte­rest’ under the GDPR. ## What this means for online retail­ers Online retail­ers who use shop­ping bas­ket remin­ders should careful­ly review their prac­ti­ces. Wit­hout the cus­to­mers’ expli­cit con­sent or the abo­ve-men­tio­ned con­di­ti­ons for exis­ting cus­to­mers, they risk fines and for­mal war­nings. Anyo­ne who does not wish to fore­go this mar­ke­ting stra­tegy should adapt their regis­tra­ti­on pro­cess accor­din­gly and ensu­re it is legal­ly com­pli­ant. Indi­vi­du­al legal advice is recom­men­ded, as the requi­re­ments may vary from case to case. Source: [Hau­fe: Recht](https://www.haufe.de/recht/weitere-rechtsgebiete/warenkorberinnerungen-per-e-mail-sind-unzulaessige-werbung_216_692002.html) This artic­le and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the sup­port of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.