Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Working from home and lunch breaks: When does accident insurance cover apply?

Working from home and lunch breaks: The Hes­si­an Regio­nal Social Court cla­ri­fies when the jour­ney to get lunch is con­side­red an acci­dent at work. 
Working from home and lunch breaks: When does accident insurance cover apply?

Working from home and lunch breaks: When does accident insurance cover apply?

Anyo­ne working from home who has an acci­dent during their lunch break is not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly cover­ed by sta­tu­to­ry acci­dent insu­rance. In two jud­ge­ments han­ded down in 2026, the Hes­si­an Regio­nal Social Court cla­ri­fied the con­di­ti­ons under which the jour­ney to have lunch is con­side­red an insu­red acci­dent at work.

An overview of the two cases

In the first case, a full-time employee work­ed from home during the coro­na­vi­rus pan­de­mic at her employer’s request. On her way to a snack bar to pick up her lunch, she fell on the pave­ment and bro­ke her upper arm. The rele­vant employ­ers’ lia­bi­li­ty insu­rance asso­cia­ti­on refu­sed to reco­g­ni­se this as an acci­dent at work.

In the second case, an employee was working fle­xi­ble hours and had the free­dom to choo­se whe­re to work. On the day of the acci­dent, he was working on a colleague’s ter­race. As he retur­ned from a snack bar and was wal­king down the stairs to the ter­race, he tore his cru­cia­te liga­ment. Here, too, the employ­ers’ lia­bi­li­ty insu­rance asso­cia­ti­on refu­sed to reco­g­ni­se the inju­ry as work-related.

What the court ruled

In the first case, the Hes­si­an Regio­nal Social Court reco­g­nis­ed the inci­dent as an insu­red acci­dent at work; in the second, it did not. Accor­ding to the jud­ge­ments, two con­di­ti­ons are decisi­ve, and both must be met simultaneously.

  • Trend:The pro­gram­me must be desi­gned to main­tain the abili­ty to work, i.e. to help ensu­re that work can be con­tin­ued afterwards.
  • Ope­ra­tio­nal reasons:The jour­ney must be made becau­se the per­son is requi­red to car­ry out work-rela­ted duties and must be pre­sent at a spe­ci­fic location.

In the first case, the clai­mant was inte­gra­ted into the company’s ope­ra­tio­nal orga­ni­sa­ti­on through fixed appoint­ments befo­re and after her lunch break. She had infor­med her col­le­agues that she would be taking her lunch break and had regis­tered the day as a day working from home. The court the­r­e­fo­re con­side­red that the­re was a suf­fi­ci­ent link to the business.

In the second case, that was pre­cis­e­ly what was miss­ing. The clai­mant was free to orga­ni­se his own work, had no fixed appoint­ments and no pre­scri­bed break times. Fur­ther­mo­re, he had alre­a­dy work­ed four and a half of the agreed six hours. The court the­r­e­fo­re ruled that the meal no lon­ger ser­ved the pur­po­se of main­tai­ning his working capa­ci­ty for the rema­in­der of his working hours.

An important boundary: the front door

The­re is an important distinc­tion for anyo­ne working from home. The court con­firm­ed that the front door of the house marks the boun­da­ry bet­ween the insu­red work­place and the pri­va­te sphe­re. Anyo­ne lea­ving the house is on their way to work, for which insu­rance cover may app­ly. The acci­dent insi­de the house whilst on the way to the ter­race in the second case, howe­ver, did not con­sti­tu­te an insu­red jour­ney to work.

What does this mean for staff working from home?

The­se rulings show that sta­tu­to­ry acci­dent insu­rance cover can cer­tain­ly app­ly when working from home, but it is not a given. Anyo­ne who is firm­ly inte­gra­ted into the company’s day-to-day ope­ra­ti­ons – that is, who has appoint­ments and has to sign in and out with col­le­agues – is more likely to be cover­ed by insu­rance than someone who works com­ple­te­ly inde­pendent­ly and flexibly.

Neither of the­se jud­ge­ments is yet final. Appeals are pen­ding befo­re the Fede­ral Social Court under case num­bers B 2 U 8/26 R and B 2 U 9/26 R. In case of doubt, tho­se affec­ted should seek legal advice.

Hes­si­an Social Court, jud­ge­ments of 25 June 2026, Case No. L 3 U 189/24, and of 19 May 2026, Case No. L 3 U 176/25

Source: Hau­fe: Law

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this