Anyone working from home who has an accident during their lunch break is not automatically covered by statutory accident insurance. In two judgements handed down in 2026, the Hessian Regional Social Court clarified the conditions under which the journey to have lunch is considered an insured accident at work.
An overview of the two cases
In the first case, a full-time employee worked from home during the coronavirus pandemic at her employer’s request. On her way to a snack bar to pick up her lunch, she fell on the pavement and broke her upper arm. The relevant employers’ liability insurance association refused to recognise this as an accident at work.
In the second case, an employee was working flexible hours and had the freedom to choose where to work. On the day of the accident, he was working on a colleague’s terrace. As he returned from a snack bar and was walking down the stairs to the terrace, he tore his cruciate ligament. Here, too, the employers’ liability insurance association refused to recognise the injury as work-related.
What the court ruled
In the first case, the Hessian Regional Social Court recognised the incident as an insured accident at work; in the second, it did not. According to the judgements, two conditions are decisive, and both must be met simultaneously.
- Trend:The programme must be designed to maintain the ability to work, i.e. to help ensure that work can be continued afterwards.
- Operational reasons:The journey must be made because the person is required to carry out work-related duties and must be present at a specific location.
In the first case, the claimant was integrated into the company’s operational organisation through fixed appointments before and after her lunch break. She had informed her colleagues that she would be taking her lunch break and had registered the day as a day working from home. The court therefore considered that there was a sufficient link to the business.
In the second case, that was precisely what was missing. The claimant was free to organise his own work, had no fixed appointments and no prescribed break times. Furthermore, he had already worked four and a half of the agreed six hours. The court therefore ruled that the meal no longer served the purpose of maintaining his working capacity for the remainder of his working hours.
An important boundary: the front door
There is an important distinction for anyone working from home. The court confirmed that the front door of the house marks the boundary between the insured workplace and the private sphere. Anyone leaving the house is on their way to work, for which insurance cover may apply. The accident inside the house whilst on the way to the terrace in the second case, however, did not constitute an insured journey to work.
What does this mean for staff working from home?
These rulings show that statutory accident insurance cover can certainly apply when working from home, but it is not a given. Anyone who is firmly integrated into the company’s day-to-day operations – that is, who has appointments and has to sign in and out with colleagues – is more likely to be covered by insurance than someone who works completely independently and flexibly.
Neither of these judgements is yet final. Appeals are pending before the Federal Social Court under case numbers B 2 U 8/26 R and B 2 U 9/26 R. In case of doubt, those affected should seek legal advice.
Hessian Social Court, judgements of 25 June 2026, Case No. L 3 U 189/24, and of 19 May 2026, Case No. L 3 U 176/25
Source: Haufe: Law
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.